In the 1988 vice presidential debates, Democratic nominee Lloyd Bentsen shoved a rhetorical shiv deep into George H. W. Bush's running mate Dan Quayle. Quayle somehow compared himself to John F. Kennedy and Bentsen responded with one of the great defining "gotchas" in debate history. "You, sir, are no Jack Kennedy."
Bentsen wanted to take a dig at Quayle, sure. But his greater intent lay in showing that Dan Quayle was not a serious enough individual to be so close to presidential power. Bentsen may have been right or wrong about that assumption, and curiously enough, he actually was not a friend of Kennedy's. But he did speak to the hearts of many who do worry about the White House not being in serious hands.
A little over 50 years ago, Kennedy confronted Cuba and the Soviet Union over missiles placed there by the Communist nations. Doing nothing meant accepting a mortal threat to the southeastern United States. Too much response could lead to regional or even global war. Kennedy knew about the missiles for some time before the public. In October 1962, it became international news. The president took 13 days to craft his response.
During the entire time, Kennedy met with a specially convened executive committee, nicknamed "ExCom." This committee included representatives from the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the National Security Committee, the Secretary of State, the Attorney General, and others. Kennedy observed as they debated every possible option. From watching these debates, Kennedy was able to intelligently rule out some options, such as air strikes and invasions, while putting together the best peaceable alternatives. He preserved American integrity while achieving the national goal. Whatever other faults he had, John F. Kennedy knew how to use and listen to advisers during a world crisis.
Yesterday, Obama's top team on Syria met with congressional representatives to discuss US options. Meanwhile, Obama met with Magic Johnson.
That alone should be an impeachable offense. This man does not take his job seriously. He has no sense of priorities.
Friday, August 30, 2013
Wednesday, August 28, 2013
Unleashing the Dogs of War . . . Or At Least A Limited Strike
The worst kept secret on the planet right now is that the United States, and perhaps other allies as well, will launch some sort of attack on Syria in the near future.
Last summer, Obama declared that one of his "red lines" was the use of weapons of mass destruction. Last week, someone in the Assad "administration" apparently used them to kill, among others, many hundreds of civilians.
US intelligence sources cite a strange intercepted phone call within the Syrian government camp as proof. A Syrian defense official demanded an explanation for why chemical weapons were launched. If one was forthcoming, the rationale has not yet been released.
This raises questions about the Syrian government. Was the attack the work of a rogue officer? Was it a direct order from the highest levels of government? Is the Syrian government even a cohesive unit anymore?
In any event, Obama and British Prime Minister David Cameron seem to agree that a response must occur.
Cameron plans to consult with Parliament. At this time, however, Obama seems to have no plans to request authorization from Congress. Although some congressional Republicans have offered muted support, Senator Rand Paul (Ky.) claimed that Syrian events had "no clear national security connection" to the United States. Paul did not rule out action, but asked that Obama consult with Congress meaningfully before acting.
In this case, rushing to action within a few days does not seem absolutely necessary. The repulsiveness of the attack is not likely to wear out. Indeed the United Nations investigators will undoubtedly either uncover more evidence and details that maintain world disgust, or Syrian officials will block them entirely. The UN has requested four days, which does not seem unreasonable. President George W. Bush gave them much longer before launching war against Iraq.
Syria presents US policy makers considerable trouble. The rebel targets of government chemical weapons have shown themselves no less murderous than Assad's thugs. Islamicist rebels have slaughtered Roman Catholic clergy among many other innocents during their own reign of terror.
President Bush had some "good guys" to work with when he overturned Saddam Hussein's thugocracy. Syria seems to have few or no credible leaders who could make a peaceful republic work.
This limits Obama's options. Any Iraq style invasion would require a much more powerful force prepared to stay in place for much longer. Nation building would by necessity look more like colonization.
Any boots on the ground would likely end badly for the United States. In the mid 1980s, President Reagan deployed Marines to serve as part of a peacekeeping unit to try and bring stability to Lebanon. Terrorists killed over 200. After a few good-bye blasts from the USS New Jersey, American forces skedaddled.
The various Lebanese factions had no desire to play nice just because American and European soldiers showed up. They continued killing each other and blowing up heaps of rubble until they exhausted their will to fight. Lebanon has remained relatively peaceable ever since.
So ground based combat forces will not work.
That leaves air strikes and/or covert operations. The CIA does need to infiltrate Syria. To make reasonable decisions, American leaders need to have knowledge of what is going on and who makes it happen. It needs to monitor individuals and groups as they refine terror techniques. Covert teams can also find locations of important sites in case stronger military action is required.
Air strikes would have to be very precise and specific. Former Representative and anti-war crusader Dennis Kucinich noted that air strikes by American planes would make them Al Qaeda's air force. Indiscriminate targeting of Syrian government military forces would help clear the road for an even worse regime. Conversely, firing a couple of Tomahawk missiles in the general direction of Assad makes American power look downright petty and even silly.
Take the time to identify chemical weapons facilities. Only target them. Use weapons capable of doing the job, like daisy cutters. Cruise missiles may not deliver enough punch. This will achieve a limited goal and curb WMD attacks in the future without overly involving the US or using military action as a public relations stunt.
Obama must also prepare to stand by Israel. Attacks on Syria may provoke a response against Israel. Specific tactical actions may be necessary against any force deployed to strike Israel. On the other hand, it is difficult to see how effectively Syria could strike Israel while struggling in its own civil war.
Obama must make wise decisions here, stick by them, and articulate explanations. He must have the specific goal of curbing WMD usage while rebuilding respect for American power. If he covers his bases with Congress and the United Nations, this could help reconstruct respect for US foreign policy that has fallen greatly since Bush left office.
Many unmarked cliffs and chasms loom in the road ahead. Obama will have to tread carefully as he acts.
Last summer, Obama declared that one of his "red lines" was the use of weapons of mass destruction. Last week, someone in the Assad "administration" apparently used them to kill, among others, many hundreds of civilians.
US intelligence sources cite a strange intercepted phone call within the Syrian government camp as proof. A Syrian defense official demanded an explanation for why chemical weapons were launched. If one was forthcoming, the rationale has not yet been released.
This raises questions about the Syrian government. Was the attack the work of a rogue officer? Was it a direct order from the highest levels of government? Is the Syrian government even a cohesive unit anymore?
In any event, Obama and British Prime Minister David Cameron seem to agree that a response must occur.
Cameron plans to consult with Parliament. At this time, however, Obama seems to have no plans to request authorization from Congress. Although some congressional Republicans have offered muted support, Senator Rand Paul (Ky.) claimed that Syrian events had "no clear national security connection" to the United States. Paul did not rule out action, but asked that Obama consult with Congress meaningfully before acting.
In this case, rushing to action within a few days does not seem absolutely necessary. The repulsiveness of the attack is not likely to wear out. Indeed the United Nations investigators will undoubtedly either uncover more evidence and details that maintain world disgust, or Syrian officials will block them entirely. The UN has requested four days, which does not seem unreasonable. President George W. Bush gave them much longer before launching war against Iraq.
Syria presents US policy makers considerable trouble. The rebel targets of government chemical weapons have shown themselves no less murderous than Assad's thugs. Islamicist rebels have slaughtered Roman Catholic clergy among many other innocents during their own reign of terror.
President Bush had some "good guys" to work with when he overturned Saddam Hussein's thugocracy. Syria seems to have few or no credible leaders who could make a peaceful republic work.
This limits Obama's options. Any Iraq style invasion would require a much more powerful force prepared to stay in place for much longer. Nation building would by necessity look more like colonization.
Any boots on the ground would likely end badly for the United States. In the mid 1980s, President Reagan deployed Marines to serve as part of a peacekeeping unit to try and bring stability to Lebanon. Terrorists killed over 200. After a few good-bye blasts from the USS New Jersey, American forces skedaddled.
The various Lebanese factions had no desire to play nice just because American and European soldiers showed up. They continued killing each other and blowing up heaps of rubble until they exhausted their will to fight. Lebanon has remained relatively peaceable ever since.
So ground based combat forces will not work.
That leaves air strikes and/or covert operations. The CIA does need to infiltrate Syria. To make reasonable decisions, American leaders need to have knowledge of what is going on and who makes it happen. It needs to monitor individuals and groups as they refine terror techniques. Covert teams can also find locations of important sites in case stronger military action is required.
Air strikes would have to be very precise and specific. Former Representative and anti-war crusader Dennis Kucinich noted that air strikes by American planes would make them Al Qaeda's air force. Indiscriminate targeting of Syrian government military forces would help clear the road for an even worse regime. Conversely, firing a couple of Tomahawk missiles in the general direction of Assad makes American power look downright petty and even silly.
Take the time to identify chemical weapons facilities. Only target them. Use weapons capable of doing the job, like daisy cutters. Cruise missiles may not deliver enough punch. This will achieve a limited goal and curb WMD attacks in the future without overly involving the US or using military action as a public relations stunt.
Obama must also prepare to stand by Israel. Attacks on Syria may provoke a response against Israel. Specific tactical actions may be necessary against any force deployed to strike Israel. On the other hand, it is difficult to see how effectively Syria could strike Israel while struggling in its own civil war.
Obama must make wise decisions here, stick by them, and articulate explanations. He must have the specific goal of curbing WMD usage while rebuilding respect for American power. If he covers his bases with Congress and the United Nations, this could help reconstruct respect for US foreign policy that has fallen greatly since Bush left office.
Many unmarked cliffs and chasms loom in the road ahead. Obama will have to tread carefully as he acts.
Labels:
Al Qua'ida,
Barack Obama,
chemical weapons,
CIA,
Congress,
Israel,
Lebanon,
Rand Paul,
Ronald Reagan,
Syria,
Terrorism
Transcript of Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I Have A Dream Speech" 50 Years Later
Transcript of Martin Luther King Jr.'s 'I have a dream' speech
Published August 27, 2013
| FoxNews.com
advertisement
I am happy to join with you today in what will go down in history as the greatest demonstration for freedom in the history of our nation.
Five score years ago, a great American, in whose symbolic shadow we stand today, signed the Emancipation Proclamation. This momentous decree came as a great beacon light of hope to millions of Negro slaves who had been seared in the flames of withering injustice. It came as a joyous daybreak to end the long night of their captivity.
But 100 years later, the Negro still is not free. One hundred years later, the life of the Negro is still sadly crippled by the manacles of segregation and the chains of discrimination. One hundred years later, the Negro lives on a lonely island of poverty in the midst of a vast ocean of material prosperity. One hundred years later, the Negro is still languished in the corners of American society and finds himself an exile in his own land. And so we've come here today to dramatize a shameful condition.
In a sense we've come to our nation's capital to cash a check. When the architects of our republic wrote the magnificent words of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, they were signing a promissory note to which every American was to fall heir. This note was a promise that all men -- yes, black men as well as white men -- would be guaranteed the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
It is obvious today that America has defaulted on this promissory note insofar as her citizens of color are concerned. Instead of honoring this sacred obligation, America has given the Negro people a bad check, a check that has come back marked "insufficient funds."
But we refuse to believe that the bank of justice is bankrupt. We refuse to believe that there are insufficient funds in the great vaults of opportunity of this nation. And so we've come to cash this check, a check that will give us upon demand the riches of freedom and security of justice. We have also come to this hallowed spot to remind America of the fierce urgency of now. This is no time to engage in the luxury of cooling off or to take the tranquilizing drug of gradualism. Now is the time to make real the promises of democracy. Now is the time to rise from the dark and desolate valley of segregation to the sunlit path of racial justice. Now is the time to lift our nation from the quicksands of racial injustice to the solid rock of brotherhood. Now is the time to make justice a reality for all of God's children.
It would be fatal for the nation to overlook the urgency of the moment. This sweltering summer of the Negro's legitimate discontent will not pass until there is an invigorating autumn of freedom and equality. 1963 is not an end but a beginning. Those who hoped that the Negro needed to blow off steam and will now be content will have a rude awakening if the nation returns to business as usual. There will be neither rest nor tranquility in America until the Negro is granted his citizenship rights. The whirlwinds of revolt will continue to shake the foundations of our nation until the bright day of justice emerges.
But there is something that I must say to my people who stand on the warm threshold which leads into the palace of justice. In the process of gaining our rightful place we must not be guilty of wrongful deeds. Let us not seek to satisfy our thirst for freedom by drinking from the cup of bitterness and hatred. We must forever conduct our struggle on the high plane of dignity and discipline. We must not allow our creative protest to degenerate into physical violence. Again and again we must rise to the majestic heights of meeting physical force with soul force. The marvelous new militancy which has engulfed the Negro community must not lead us to a distrust of all white people, for many of our white brothers, as evidenced by their presence here today, have come to realize that their destiny is tied up with our destiny. And they have come to realize that their freedom is inextricably bound to our freedom. We cannot walk alone.
As we walk, we must make the pledge that we shall always march ahead. We cannot turn back. There are those who are asking the devotees of civil rights, "When will you be satisfied?" We can never be satisfied as long as the Negro is the victim of the unspeakable horrors of police brutality. We can never be satisfied as long as our bodies, heavy with the fatigue of travel, cannot gain lodging in the motels of the highways and the hotels of the cities. We cannot be satisfied as long as the Negro's basic mobility is from a smaller ghetto to a larger one. We can never be satisfied as long as our children are stripped of their selfhood and robbed of their dignity by signs stating "for whites only." We cannot be satisfied as long as a Negro in Mississippi cannot vote and a Negro in New York believes he has nothing for which to vote. No, no we are not satisfied and we will not be satisfied until justice rolls down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream.
I am not unmindful that some of you have come here out of great trials and tribulations. Some of you have come fresh from narrow jail cells. Some of you have come from areas where your quest for freedom left you battered by storms of persecution and staggered by the winds of police brutality. You have been the veterans of creative suffering. Continue to work with the faith that unearned suffering is redemptive.
Go back to Mississippi, go back to Alabama, go back to South Carolina, go back to Georgia, go back to Louisiana, go back to the slums and ghettos of our northern cities, knowing that somehow this situation can and will be changed.
Let us not wallow in the valley of despair. I say to you today my friends -- so even though we face the difficulties of today and tomorrow, I still have a dream. It is a dream deeply rooted in the American dream.
I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal."
I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood.
I have a dream that one day even the state of Mississippi, a state sweltering with the heat of injustice, sweltering with the heat of oppression, will be transformed into an oasis of freedom and justice.
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.
I have a dream today.
I have a dream that one day down in Alabama, with its vicious racists, with its governor having his lips dripping with the words of interposition and nullification -- one day right there in Alabama little black boys and black girls will be able to join hands with little white boys and white girls as sisters and brothers.
I have a dream today.
I have a dream that one day every valley shall be exalted, and every hill and mountain shall be made low, the rough places will be made plain, and the crooked places will be made straight, and the glory of the Lord shall be revealed and all flesh shall see it together.
This is our hope. This is the faith that I go back to the South with. With this faith we will be able to hew out of the mountain of despair a stone of hope. With this faith we will be able to transform the jangling discords of our nation into a beautiful symphony of brotherhood. With this faith we will be able to work together, to pray together, to struggle together, to go to jail together, to stand up for freedom together, knowing that we will be free one day.
This will be the day, this will be the day when all of God's children will be able to sing with new meaning "My country 'tis of thee, sweet land of liberty, of thee I sing. Land where my father's died, land of the Pilgrim's pride, from every mountainside, let freedom ring!"
And if America is to be a great nation, this must become true. And so let freedom ring from the prodigious hilltops of New Hampshire. Let freedom ring from the mighty mountains of New York. Let freedom ring from the heightening Alleghenies of Pennsylvania.
Let freedom ring from the snow-capped Rockies of Colorado. Let freedom ring from the curvaceous slopes of California.
But not only that; let freedom ring from Stone Mountain of Georgia.
Let freedom ring from Lookout Mountain of Tennessee.
Let freedom ring from every hill and molehill of Mississippi -- from every mountainside.
Let freedom ring. And when this happens, and when we allow freedom ring -- when we let it ring from every village and every hamlet, from every state and every city, we will be able to speed up that day when all of God's children -- black men and white men, Jews and Gentiles, Protestants and Catholics -- will be able to join hands and sing in the words of the old Negro spiritual: "Free at last! Free at last! Thank God Almighty, we are free at last!"
Read more: http://www.foxnews.com/us/2013/08/27/transcript-martin-luther-king-jr-have-dream-speech/print#ixzz2dGwH0sSC
Monday, August 26, 2013
Universities That Begged For Subsidies Now Fight Obama's Power Grab
They begged for them and got them. But at what price?
The college and university system in the United States fought long and hard to obtain as much student aid and tuition subsidies as possible from the federal government. And now, Washington Examiner columnist Tim Carney explains that their chickens have come home to roost.
Last week, Obama gave a higher education speech. It addressed the endless upward spiral of tuition and debt, as well as the declining value of a college education in many fields. What was Obama's idea? As usual, let the federal government handle it.
Obama proposed that the federal government rate colleges (based on what criteria!) to determine which offered the best educational value. Suddenly, hard bitten liberal and left wing academics protested like Tea Party activists about the potential for political abuse.
Carney quoted former Harvard president Derek Bok, "I have to be somewhat apprehensive when any force as powerful as the federal government undertakes the task."
William and Mary economics department chair David H. Feldman warned in the Chronicle of Higher Education that tying outcomes to funding would force colleges and universities to reject at-risk students who could come and do well otherwise.
Others say that the information proposed as a baseline to analysis is incomplete.
The universities themselves invited this bind. They begged for the subsidies and got them. Then, as years passed, they built dorms that would make an Embassy Suites blush. They bloated salaries, travel budgets, and other perquisites of office. Higher education went on spending sprees, leaving faculty salaries and cash strapped students in the dust.
Now the federal government proposes to meddle in higher education in the same way that it has ripped apart the public school systems. Killing it with kindly bureaucratic help.
Interestingly, all that stands in the way of Obama is House Republicans. Congress has refused to authorize the sweeping data collection needed by the federal government to implement this. That being said, some conservatives may agree that the federal government deserves more bang for its buck. It is not as if academia has ever given Republicans a reason to offer a helping hand.
Not to mention that overspending taxpayer funds created this mess for the colleges
Will left wing higher education-ocrats deign to work with the Republican Party? Stay tuned!
The college and university system in the United States fought long and hard to obtain as much student aid and tuition subsidies as possible from the federal government. And now, Washington Examiner columnist Tim Carney explains that their chickens have come home to roost.
Last week, Obama gave a higher education speech. It addressed the endless upward spiral of tuition and debt, as well as the declining value of a college education in many fields. What was Obama's idea? As usual, let the federal government handle it.
Obama proposed that the federal government rate colleges (based on what criteria!) to determine which offered the best educational value. Suddenly, hard bitten liberal and left wing academics protested like Tea Party activists about the potential for political abuse.
Carney quoted former Harvard president Derek Bok, "I have to be somewhat apprehensive when any force as powerful as the federal government undertakes the task."
William and Mary economics department chair David H. Feldman warned in the Chronicle of Higher Education that tying outcomes to funding would force colleges and universities to reject at-risk students who could come and do well otherwise.
Others say that the information proposed as a baseline to analysis is incomplete.
The universities themselves invited this bind. They begged for the subsidies and got them. Then, as years passed, they built dorms that would make an Embassy Suites blush. They bloated salaries, travel budgets, and other perquisites of office. Higher education went on spending sprees, leaving faculty salaries and cash strapped students in the dust.
Now the federal government proposes to meddle in higher education in the same way that it has ripped apart the public school systems. Killing it with kindly bureaucratic help.
Interestingly, all that stands in the way of Obama is House Republicans. Congress has refused to authorize the sweeping data collection needed by the federal government to implement this. That being said, some conservatives may agree that the federal government deserves more bang for its buck. It is not as if academia has ever given Republicans a reason to offer a helping hand.
Not to mention that overspending taxpayer funds created this mess for the colleges
Will left wing higher education-ocrats deign to work with the Republican Party? Stay tuned!
Thursday, August 22, 2013
Death Comes to Syria and Egypt
Someone attacked a suburb of Damascus, Syria this week with all the quiet fury of a Biblical plague. No marks of sacrificial blood could save the innocent or chosen. This work of man killed all indiscriminately.
Nerve gas wafted through the streets and homes. By the time it dissipated, it killed 1,300 just as effectively as the Japanese at Nanking or the Romans at Carthage in the Third Punic War.
The Daily Mail referred to the incident as "the town that never woke up."
The Syrian belligerents can be divided into three categories. First is the Syrian government itself, no stranger to atrocities. Rebelling against it is one group with an equal potential for evil, the Islamicists. Kurdish forces in the northeast have seized important points. Kurds have a quasi-sovereign state in northern Iraq, but also live in Syria, Turkey, and Iran. Possibly the weakest faction is the Syrian nationalist rebels, tied by outrageous fortune to the Islamicists.
Government forces showed signs of desperation earlier this week when they attacked the Israeli held Golan Heights. Provoking a war with Israel would throw the region into chaos. Israel, so far, has remained somewhat restrained.
A group allied with the Syrian government took down the Washington Post's website last week.
The Washington Free Beacon reported a day before the attack that a joint Russian-American plan to create a transitional government has not taken the first necessary steps.
Meanwhile in Egypt, as was reported yesterday by Kirby Wilbur on the Sean Hannity Show, Muslim Brotherhood thugs, ousted by the military, have taken their rage out on the Coptic Christian community.
American influence since World War II has not brought complete peace, but has kept the lid on conflicts that could have erupted without its presence. US troops have occasionally played a role, as in Lebanon under Eisenhower and Reagan. This also, of course, includes the Iraq wars. But usually US aims are realized through the dispensation of aid and realpolitik style maneuvering.
Some of these conflicts, such as the rise of the Islamofascist thug group, Muslim Brotherhood, have steadily percolated for years. The Brotherhood aligned with the Nazis before and during World War II to try and destabilize British authority in the Middle East. Ever since, they have worked to undermine secular rule in Egypt to establish an Iran or Taliban style state there.
The full realization of their plans would put a hostile power in control of the vital Suez Canal who also would attack Israel.
Part of the problem lies at the feet of Barack Obama. Nearly every president since Harry Truman has based American Middle East policy on certain foundations. First was support of Israel. Second, America must protect, or support the protection of, strategic interests. These include safe ocean passage through the Suez, Straits of Hormuz, etc., oil reserves, and important points.
The United States also worked to prevent the rise of malefactors in the Middle East, but also lived with anti-democratic forces willing to go along with the game plan. For example, Qaddafi was an enemy when he sponsored terrorism. When he renounced weapons of mass destruction, he became at least tolerable and a possible example of a "reformed" dictator. Not the best case scenario, but an improvement.
Supporting "democracy" in the Middle East is problematic. Islamofascists, like the German Nazis and Communists before, advocate "democracy" so that they can come to power and annihilate it. The best case scenario for Germany in the mid 1930s would have been a military coup and purge of Hitler's followers and Communists, followed by a restoration of the Kaiser. Those rebelling against authoritarianism today often only plan to establish bloody totalitarianism tomorrow.
Previous presidents understood this. Obama does not.
American policy in the region has no chance of restoration under Obama. His aimless diplomacy, coupled with two poorly performing secretaries of state, inspire no respect. Middle Easterners did not always like Obama's predecessor, but they respected his strength and ability to act. Obama has effectively destroyed that perception and replaced it with weakness.
Drifting away from Israel has also made war more likely, not less.
Even though energy self-sufficiency will de-emphasize the Middle East's importance somewhat, it still breeds hate and terror. America must have a policy that starts with a perception of strength based on the reality of action. Doing anything else increases the chance of war and/or terror attacks.
Nerve gas wafted through the streets and homes. By the time it dissipated, it killed 1,300 just as effectively as the Japanese at Nanking or the Romans at Carthage in the Third Punic War.
The Daily Mail referred to the incident as "the town that never woke up."
The Syrian belligerents can be divided into three categories. First is the Syrian government itself, no stranger to atrocities. Rebelling against it is one group with an equal potential for evil, the Islamicists. Kurdish forces in the northeast have seized important points. Kurds have a quasi-sovereign state in northern Iraq, but also live in Syria, Turkey, and Iran. Possibly the weakest faction is the Syrian nationalist rebels, tied by outrageous fortune to the Islamicists.
Government forces showed signs of desperation earlier this week when they attacked the Israeli held Golan Heights. Provoking a war with Israel would throw the region into chaos. Israel, so far, has remained somewhat restrained.
A group allied with the Syrian government took down the Washington Post's website last week.
The Washington Free Beacon reported a day before the attack that a joint Russian-American plan to create a transitional government has not taken the first necessary steps.
Meanwhile in Egypt, as was reported yesterday by Kirby Wilbur on the Sean Hannity Show, Muslim Brotherhood thugs, ousted by the military, have taken their rage out on the Coptic Christian community.
American influence since World War II has not brought complete peace, but has kept the lid on conflicts that could have erupted without its presence. US troops have occasionally played a role, as in Lebanon under Eisenhower and Reagan. This also, of course, includes the Iraq wars. But usually US aims are realized through the dispensation of aid and realpolitik style maneuvering.
Some of these conflicts, such as the rise of the Islamofascist thug group, Muslim Brotherhood, have steadily percolated for years. The Brotherhood aligned with the Nazis before and during World War II to try and destabilize British authority in the Middle East. Ever since, they have worked to undermine secular rule in Egypt to establish an Iran or Taliban style state there.
The full realization of their plans would put a hostile power in control of the vital Suez Canal who also would attack Israel.
Part of the problem lies at the feet of Barack Obama. Nearly every president since Harry Truman has based American Middle East policy on certain foundations. First was support of Israel. Second, America must protect, or support the protection of, strategic interests. These include safe ocean passage through the Suez, Straits of Hormuz, etc., oil reserves, and important points.
The United States also worked to prevent the rise of malefactors in the Middle East, but also lived with anti-democratic forces willing to go along with the game plan. For example, Qaddafi was an enemy when he sponsored terrorism. When he renounced weapons of mass destruction, he became at least tolerable and a possible example of a "reformed" dictator. Not the best case scenario, but an improvement.
Supporting "democracy" in the Middle East is problematic. Islamofascists, like the German Nazis and Communists before, advocate "democracy" so that they can come to power and annihilate it. The best case scenario for Germany in the mid 1930s would have been a military coup and purge of Hitler's followers and Communists, followed by a restoration of the Kaiser. Those rebelling against authoritarianism today often only plan to establish bloody totalitarianism tomorrow.
Previous presidents understood this. Obama does not.
American policy in the region has no chance of restoration under Obama. His aimless diplomacy, coupled with two poorly performing secretaries of state, inspire no respect. Middle Easterners did not always like Obama's predecessor, but they respected his strength and ability to act. Obama has effectively destroyed that perception and replaced it with weakness.
Drifting away from Israel has also made war more likely, not less.
Even though energy self-sufficiency will de-emphasize the Middle East's importance somewhat, it still breeds hate and terror. America must have a policy that starts with a perception of strength based on the reality of action. Doing anything else increases the chance of war and/or terror attacks.
Wednesday, August 21, 2013
Obama, Dick, and Andy: "I Wanna Talk About Me"
About a year ago, Barack Obama caused a personal pronoun stir when CNSNews.com reported that he used the first person pronouns "I" and "me" a combined total of 117 times in a single speech. But, however, Obama is far from alone in "wanting to talk about me."
About a year and six weeks before the oft reported July 2012 speech, blogger Marc Cenedella reported an analysis of Obama speeches given at CIA headquarters compared with several of his predecessors. Since 1968, Presidents Carter, Reagan, and George W. Bush referred to themselves the least often. George H. W. Bush gets a pass for a slightly higher level because he once was CIA chief, which would lead to more first person mentions.
By far, the three highest levels of use came from Richard Nixon, Bill Clinton, and Barack Obama. Clinton's high use shrinks when Cenedella factors in the length of the addresses. The famously loquacious Clinton drops down to Bushian levels of first person pronoun use while Obama and Nixon remain higher than the rest.
In his 1960 work Andrew Johnson and Reconstruction, famed American historian Eric McKitrick examined another president persistent in his employment of first person pronouns.
About Johnson, he wrote :
For a public man, he was obsessed with himself to a degree that exceeded the normal, and most of his speeches, no matter what else they dealt with, may be read as demands for personal vindication and personal approval.
McKitrick also concluded that Johnson preferred general rules to concrete thinking "in order that (his mind) might once more close itself and be at rest."
Johnson, at his worst, often evoked images of crucifixion and Judah Iscariot-like betrayal in reference to himself and his enemies. This worked in the East Tennessee hills where the poor felt just as nailed to a cross by their betters as he did. But it fell short of the expectations that the national public had for the demeanor of their president.
McKitrick compared the inferiority complex of Johnson to the confidence of Lincoln. About the 16th president, he said his "'humility' was sustained by the odd arrogance of a superior man's self-knowledge." Interestingly, this also describes President Reagan and both chief executives of the Bush family.
Nixon's public speaking patterns mimicked McKitrick's evaluation of Johnson, especially early. Journalist Theodore White remembered almost a decade later that in 1960, Nixon's "common utterances all too frequently a mixture of pathetic self-pity and petulant distemper." Aide Robert Finch told White in 1968 that Nixon" doesn't want to be loved. He's not looking for adulation the way he used to." But that campaign evaluation looks more like Nixon covering than transforming his nature.
The three presidents all share in common some attributes. All three worked to expand the authority of the executive branch. None of them could work and play well with anyone except their closest trusted associates. All three had fatal flaws that kept them from functioning comfortably in the role chosen for them by the public. Nixon enjoyed the most success, but of course unraveled his legacy by covering criminal activities. Obama and Nixon both preferred layers of secrecy to public examination of their administration's doings. Conversely, Johnson was perhaps too open about his exact feelings for proposals and personalities.
Of the three, Johnson was far and away the best speaker. He could address a crowd extemporaneously for hours. Sure, the crowds sometimes despised him after his efforts, but Johnson could never leave an audience cold. Obama reads well from a teleprompter, but may be one of the worst presidential speakers if the ability to speak and respond without notes is factored.
Will Obama's presidency end in scandal and/or disgrace as Johnson and Nixon's did? It certainly has achieved no success that has been of any value to the people. And history's remembrance of Johnson certainly has found echoes in Obama.
History will illuminate more of Obama as years and decades pass, but he has shown enough over the past several years that some conclusions are inescapable.
The most important of these is that Obama has been consistently a much smaller man than the American presidency demands.
About a year and six weeks before the oft reported July 2012 speech, blogger Marc Cenedella reported an analysis of Obama speeches given at CIA headquarters compared with several of his predecessors. Since 1968, Presidents Carter, Reagan, and George W. Bush referred to themselves the least often. George H. W. Bush gets a pass for a slightly higher level because he once was CIA chief, which would lead to more first person mentions.
By far, the three highest levels of use came from Richard Nixon, Bill Clinton, and Barack Obama. Clinton's high use shrinks when Cenedella factors in the length of the addresses. The famously loquacious Clinton drops down to Bushian levels of first person pronoun use while Obama and Nixon remain higher than the rest.
In his 1960 work Andrew Johnson and Reconstruction, famed American historian Eric McKitrick examined another president persistent in his employment of first person pronouns.
About Johnson, he wrote :
For a public man, he was obsessed with himself to a degree that exceeded the normal, and most of his speeches, no matter what else they dealt with, may be read as demands for personal vindication and personal approval.
McKitrick also concluded that Johnson preferred general rules to concrete thinking "in order that (his mind) might once more close itself and be at rest."
Johnson, at his worst, often evoked images of crucifixion and Judah Iscariot-like betrayal in reference to himself and his enemies. This worked in the East Tennessee hills where the poor felt just as nailed to a cross by their betters as he did. But it fell short of the expectations that the national public had for the demeanor of their president.
McKitrick compared the inferiority complex of Johnson to the confidence of Lincoln. About the 16th president, he said his "'humility' was sustained by the odd arrogance of a superior man's self-knowledge." Interestingly, this also describes President Reagan and both chief executives of the Bush family.
Nixon's public speaking patterns mimicked McKitrick's evaluation of Johnson, especially early. Journalist Theodore White remembered almost a decade later that in 1960, Nixon's "common utterances all too frequently a mixture of pathetic self-pity and petulant distemper." Aide Robert Finch told White in 1968 that Nixon" doesn't want to be loved. He's not looking for adulation the way he used to." But that campaign evaluation looks more like Nixon covering than transforming his nature.
The three presidents all share in common some attributes. All three worked to expand the authority of the executive branch. None of them could work and play well with anyone except their closest trusted associates. All three had fatal flaws that kept them from functioning comfortably in the role chosen for them by the public. Nixon enjoyed the most success, but of course unraveled his legacy by covering criminal activities. Obama and Nixon both preferred layers of secrecy to public examination of their administration's doings. Conversely, Johnson was perhaps too open about his exact feelings for proposals and personalities.
Of the three, Johnson was far and away the best speaker. He could address a crowd extemporaneously for hours. Sure, the crowds sometimes despised him after his efforts, but Johnson could never leave an audience cold. Obama reads well from a teleprompter, but may be one of the worst presidential speakers if the ability to speak and respond without notes is factored.
Will Obama's presidency end in scandal and/or disgrace as Johnson and Nixon's did? It certainly has achieved no success that has been of any value to the people. And history's remembrance of Johnson certainly has found echoes in Obama.
History will illuminate more of Obama as years and decades pass, but he has shown enough over the past several years that some conclusions are inescapable.
The most important of these is that Obama has been consistently a much smaller man than the American presidency demands.
Department of Transportation Shut Down 34 Bus and Trucking Firms In 2013
Last week, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration shut down The People's Choice.
According to a press release, officials found that the Hardeeville, South Carolina based bus company "failed to properly inspect, repair, or maintain" its fleet of vehicles. According to the FMCSA, it also failed to adhere to regulations limiting drivers' time on the road, dispatched "unqualified drivers," and did take enough steps to prevent possible substance abuse of those operating the buses.
The People's Choice is the 18th company shut down by the administration since the deployment of 50 "Operation Quick Strike" inspectors last April. This is part of a more aggressive strategy under Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx.
New regulations include the decrease of allowed weekly driving hours from 82 to 70. The administration estimates that this will save 19 lives and prevent 1,400 accidents per year. Drivers are also required to take scheduled breaks and limit their daily hours.
Interestingly enough, however, the new regulations specifically exempt all government drivers, including those driving school buses. That includes those transporting students across state lines to athletic and other events.
The FMCSA states that the ultimate goal is to fight and reduce chronic driver fatigue.
According to a press release, officials found that the Hardeeville, South Carolina based bus company "failed to properly inspect, repair, or maintain" its fleet of vehicles. According to the FMCSA, it also failed to adhere to regulations limiting drivers' time on the road, dispatched "unqualified drivers," and did take enough steps to prevent possible substance abuse of those operating the buses.
The People's Choice is the 18th company shut down by the administration since the deployment of 50 "Operation Quick Strike" inspectors last April. This is part of a more aggressive strategy under Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx.
New regulations include the decrease of allowed weekly driving hours from 82 to 70. The administration estimates that this will save 19 lives and prevent 1,400 accidents per year. Drivers are also required to take scheduled breaks and limit their daily hours.
Interestingly enough, however, the new regulations specifically exempt all government drivers, including those driving school buses. That includes those transporting students across state lines to athletic and other events.
The FMCSA states that the ultimate goal is to fight and reduce chronic driver fatigue.
Monday, August 19, 2013
Cato Institute Study Details Rise in West Virginia and Some Other States' Welfare Payouts
This week, Cato Institute released its 2013 version of "The Work Versus Welfare Tradeoff." This study shows the growth of welfare state by state since the last time the study was undertaken almost twenty years ago.
Twenty years since the highly touted welfare reform brokered by Bill Clinton and the Republican Congress, welfare still looks like a better deal than work. Cato says that "welfare benefits continue to outpace the income that most recipients can expect to earn from an entry level job."
In over 35 states, welfare pays more than minimum wage. In 13, it equals a staggering $15 per hour or more. Cato research found that welfare recipients would prefer to work, rather than receive payouts. On the other hand, they are reluctant to apply for what opportunities are available.
Cato focused its research not only on the Temporary Aid For Needy Families, or TANF. These cash payouts tend to be relatively low. By looking at the entire spectrum of programs, Cato saw a more complete picture of welfare's costs.
The study examines the problem from many angles. For instance, Cato found that West Virginia's annual welfare benefit, after accounting for inflation between 1995 and 2012, rose by over $4,700 per year. In 2012, the full welfare package equaled $27,727 in cash.
West Virginia ranked 28th on the list. The top states and the District of Columbia paid staggering amounts, up to nearly $50,000 per year.
Not every state saw increases. Eighteen states actually saw their payouts decline, most of these in the South and West.
West Virginia wages, however, only increased by $1,900 to $24,900 between 1995 and 2012.
Cato detailed changes in the food stamp program, housing assistance, medical assistance, and other programs when forming their conclusions.
Twenty years since the highly touted welfare reform brokered by Bill Clinton and the Republican Congress, welfare still looks like a better deal than work. Cato says that "welfare benefits continue to outpace the income that most recipients can expect to earn from an entry level job."
In over 35 states, welfare pays more than minimum wage. In 13, it equals a staggering $15 per hour or more. Cato research found that welfare recipients would prefer to work, rather than receive payouts. On the other hand, they are reluctant to apply for what opportunities are available.
Cato focused its research not only on the Temporary Aid For Needy Families, or TANF. These cash payouts tend to be relatively low. By looking at the entire spectrum of programs, Cato saw a more complete picture of welfare's costs.
The study examines the problem from many angles. For instance, Cato found that West Virginia's annual welfare benefit, after accounting for inflation between 1995 and 2012, rose by over $4,700 per year. In 2012, the full welfare package equaled $27,727 in cash.
West Virginia ranked 28th on the list. The top states and the District of Columbia paid staggering amounts, up to nearly $50,000 per year.
Not every state saw increases. Eighteen states actually saw their payouts decline, most of these in the South and West.
West Virginia wages, however, only increased by $1,900 to $24,900 between 1995 and 2012.
Cato detailed changes in the food stamp program, housing assistance, medical assistance, and other programs when forming their conclusions.
Labels:
Cato Institute,
TANF,
The Work Versus Welfare Payoff
Broadband Speeds For Schools and Libraries Should Soon Improve
Many schools and libraries now report slower internet speeds than home service, despite having, on average, over 200 times more users. That should soon change.
The Federal Communication Commission's "E Rate" program provides internet service to the nation's public schools and libraries. In response to surveys showing lower speeds, acting FCC chair Mignon Clyburn announced a plan to bring service closer to the levels enjoyed by home customers.
Problems arise from both the increasing numbers of people using the service, as well as the more digitally complicated information accessed for learning.
According to BroadbandBreakfast.com:
Reforms to be implemented to the E-Rate program include the provision of affordable, high-capacity broadband for schools and libraries, the improvement of administrative efficiency and the maximization of cost-effectiveness in purchases. The agency also said it would work to improve its data collection methods in order to be able to more fairly allocate funding and phase out funding for outdated services so that more money can be allotted to investments that will increase bandwidth
Schools in rural and urban areas should expect the same types of upgrades as well.
Since E Rate was established in 1996, internet connections in schools and libraries rose from 14 percent to nearly 100 percent, according to the FCC.
The Federal Communication Commission's "E Rate" program provides internet service to the nation's public schools and libraries. In response to surveys showing lower speeds, acting FCC chair Mignon Clyburn announced a plan to bring service closer to the levels enjoyed by home customers.
Problems arise from both the increasing numbers of people using the service, as well as the more digitally complicated information accessed for learning.
According to BroadbandBreakfast.com:
Reforms to be implemented to the E-Rate program include the provision of affordable, high-capacity broadband for schools and libraries, the improvement of administrative efficiency and the maximization of cost-effectiveness in purchases. The agency also said it would work to improve its data collection methods in order to be able to more fairly allocate funding and phase out funding for outdated services so that more money can be allotted to investments that will increase bandwidth
Schools in rural and urban areas should expect the same types of upgrades as well.
Since E Rate was established in 1996, internet connections in schools and libraries rose from 14 percent to nearly 100 percent, according to the FCC.
Friday, August 16, 2013
The Sum of All Libertarian Fears: Yesterday's Mingo County Debacle
Libertarians fear few things as much as Big Government. Imagine an evil and a Libertarian could connect it to government somehow, somewhere. They echo our Founding Fathers' concern with too much power centralized into one or a few hands. Libertarians also prefer the possibility of social misbehavior to legal correction in many cases. Not because anyone wants to see people suffering from their own bad judgment, but because no human being can be trusted to exercise authority without full accountability.
Mingo County yesterday proves their case.
In yesterday's edition, two of the most egregious federal indictments to come from a long term investigation were covered, complete with links to the indictments.
If true (because we have to assume innocence until the government proves its cases), this is a prime example of arrogance in power run amok. And it confirms every fear held by Libertarians....and libertarians, for that matter.
In one case, County Commissioner David Blaisdell leans on a local company to give him special favors under threat of pulling the lucrative deal it has with the county. He wanted snow tires for his own car with the government discount. To get what he wanted, Blaisdell allegedly threatened the store owner through voice mail.
The second case describes Judge Michael Thornsbury trying to repeatedly frame an individual only identified as "RW." Thorsnbury was sleeping with RW's wife and wanted her to leave him. She would not, so the judge used every level available to him. He tried to get a Homeland Security official to plant drugs. He tried to manipulate a grand jury. He conspired with a State Trooper to harass the poor man.
Don't be tempted to pass this off as backwoods Boss Hoggism. These men are educated individuals who lost all scruples when it came to abusing power.
What is the difference between Thornsbury and former New York Governor Eliot Spitzer? Spitzer illegally abused the power of his office to gather information to benefit his own campaign.
What is the difference between Blaisdell and the federal government? They threatened telecommunications firms to gather information to use against the Associated Press. They harassed Tea Party groups with the power of the IRS.
Mingo County's malefactors played for petty stakes. And they will go to jail for their arrogance. But too many in the federal government have abused the vast power at their fingertips. We cannot be certain that the information they obtain will not be used for political ends.
None of them will go to jail.
Libertarians and many conservatives understand the connections and fear the consequences. Mingo County's problems are not isolated issues, they are part and parcel of any government given too much power and never held to account.
Mingo County yesterday proves their case.
In yesterday's edition, two of the most egregious federal indictments to come from a long term investigation were covered, complete with links to the indictments.
If true (because we have to assume innocence until the government proves its cases), this is a prime example of arrogance in power run amok. And it confirms every fear held by Libertarians....and libertarians, for that matter.
In one case, County Commissioner David Blaisdell leans on a local company to give him special favors under threat of pulling the lucrative deal it has with the county. He wanted snow tires for his own car with the government discount. To get what he wanted, Blaisdell allegedly threatened the store owner through voice mail.
The second case describes Judge Michael Thornsbury trying to repeatedly frame an individual only identified as "RW." Thorsnbury was sleeping with RW's wife and wanted her to leave him. She would not, so the judge used every level available to him. He tried to get a Homeland Security official to plant drugs. He tried to manipulate a grand jury. He conspired with a State Trooper to harass the poor man.
Don't be tempted to pass this off as backwoods Boss Hoggism. These men are educated individuals who lost all scruples when it came to abusing power.
What is the difference between Thornsbury and former New York Governor Eliot Spitzer? Spitzer illegally abused the power of his office to gather information to benefit his own campaign.
What is the difference between Blaisdell and the federal government? They threatened telecommunications firms to gather information to use against the Associated Press. They harassed Tea Party groups with the power of the IRS.
Mingo County's malefactors played for petty stakes. And they will go to jail for their arrogance. But too many in the federal government have abused the vast power at their fingertips. We cannot be certain that the information they obtain will not be used for political ends.
None of them will go to jail.
Libertarians and many conservatives understand the connections and fear the consequences. Mingo County's problems are not isolated issues, they are part and parcel of any government given too much power and never held to account.
Thursday, August 15, 2013
The Night That the Lights Went Out In Mingo
It seemingly never ends. The tales of Mingo County corruption grow more absurd with each passing generation.
This morning, Mingo County Commissioner David Blaisden was indicted and arrested on federal charges. (Indictment)
What did he do? The Mingo County Commission had a contract to purchase tires from a local shop at a discounted rate. Blaisdell allegedly (and one uses that word loosely since he allegedly left a voice mail that was allegedly kept by the alleged victim) threatened to cut off the contract if he refused to sell discounted tires for Blaisdell's personal vehicle.
That was a prime example of ridiculous penny ante corruption mixed with an unhealthy dose of hubris.
Even worse was the indictment that followed against Circuit Judge Michael Thornsbury on unrelated charges.
Judge Thornsbury (Indictment) tried to convince the local Homeland Security officer to plant drugs in the truck of a local man identified only as RW (if on Twitter, check out #StandWithRW) RW happened to be the husband of Thornsbury's secretary. By now it's easy to guess that the judge and his secretary were having a affair.
When the drug planting scheme failed, Thornsbury tried to pack a grand jury to indict RW on grand larceny. RW was to be accused of grand larceny in the case of scrap drill bits, which a company had allowed him to salvage for free.
Needless to say, they are all Democrats.
Update: According to Hoppy Kercheval, a West Virginia State Trooper was involved in attempts to harass the unfortunate RW.
This morning, Mingo County Commissioner David Blaisden was indicted and arrested on federal charges. (Indictment)
What did he do? The Mingo County Commission had a contract to purchase tires from a local shop at a discounted rate. Blaisdell allegedly (and one uses that word loosely since he allegedly left a voice mail that was allegedly kept by the alleged victim) threatened to cut off the contract if he refused to sell discounted tires for Blaisdell's personal vehicle.
That was a prime example of ridiculous penny ante corruption mixed with an unhealthy dose of hubris.
Even worse was the indictment that followed against Circuit Judge Michael Thornsbury on unrelated charges.
Judge Thornsbury (Indictment) tried to convince the local Homeland Security officer to plant drugs in the truck of a local man identified only as RW (if on Twitter, check out #StandWithRW) RW happened to be the husband of Thornsbury's secretary. By now it's easy to guess that the judge and his secretary were having a affair.
When the drug planting scheme failed, Thornsbury tried to pack a grand jury to indict RW on grand larceny. RW was to be accused of grand larceny in the case of scrap drill bits, which a company had allowed him to salvage for free.
Needless to say, they are all Democrats.
Update: According to Hoppy Kercheval, a West Virginia State Trooper was involved in attempts to harass the unfortunate RW.
Labels:
#StandWithRW,
corruption,
David Blaisdell,
Michael Thornsbury,
Mingo County,
RW
How to Fight the Cyber Wars
Over the past few years, the United States has suffered countless cyberattacks. Some disable government agency sites, others shut down bank websites, ATMs, and other services. Others try to steal personal information that can be used for all kinds of fraud. And still other attackers simply want to cause mischief. For example, today the Assad backing "Syrian Electronic Army" shut down the Washington Post.
Business shells out a fortune to deal with cyberattacks, over $388 billion in 2011. And the expanding problems that come with it will increase as well. At some point, some system will shut down that is not just a nuisance for a business' customers, or readers of an online paper.
Some experts believe that pretty soon, people will die. McAfee Labs experts told CNN last January that nation-states will increasingly sponsor and suffer from cyberwarfare. And at some point, people will actually die as a result. That could push the online cold war into a hot phase fairly quickly.
China, Syria, Iran, among others are suspected of launching attacks. And the United States and Israel have initiated skirmishes of their own. According to an Associated Press account from last spring, the Pentagon has assembled 13 separate teams to battle the threat.
Tangential thinking....
I am wondering if the 13 different Defense Department created teams are capable on their own of engaging in this kind of warfare. Obviously they should be a part of it, especially because experts predict that military forces themselves will be targets.
But here's an idea. Bring back the Office of Strategic Services.
The OSS is the precursor of today's CIA. It wasn't the father or the grandfather as much as the crazy uncle of today's buttoned down intelligence bureaucracy. The OSS was established by Franklin Roosevelt in the early stage of World War II. He appointed noted Republican, William "Wild Bill" Donovan, who would eventually earn the rank of general.
Donovan believed in hiring the most talented people possible, regardless of background. He also never saw an idea not worth looking into. Famous playwrights and chefs served in the OSS, including Julia Child. Some ideas were simply awful, such as assembling a collection of German pornography to drop on the Reichschancellory in hopes of driving Hitler insane. Army Air Force chiefs responded that they preferred to bomb the place and kill the Fuehrer, if possible.
On the other hand, the OSS built up guerrilla movements (okay, one of them was Ho Chih Minh), undermined Vichy French control of North Africa, established contact with the head of German military intelligence, and did a fairly credible job. After all, they did start from scratch.
The OSS was famous, or infamous, for a freewheeling style. It was the home of the "so crazy it just might work" mode of operation. James Bond, with his panache and gadgetry, resembled more the agent of OSS than the MI 6 of today.
It would not work to bring back the OSS for its tangible world work in intelligence gathering and operations. We actually have too many different bureaus and organizations scrounging around. A new OSS would scour the country for top talent and channel it towards cyberwarfare, both defense and attack.
A new organization is necessary because it needs an organizational culture all its own. It may need to recruit individuals who have had parking tickets, are less than physically fit, may have consumed drygs at some point, etc. America's cyberenemies come from regimented and strictly authoritarian systems. The best way to drive them cyber crazy is to gather a freewheeling group together to foil it.
This means foiling attacks and launching our own. Find creative ways to apply Sun Tzu to the online world.
Not that previous efforts by the US been without effectiveness or creativity. When a virus shut down Iranian nuclear computers to the tune of AC/DC's "Thunderstruck," that was a nice touch.
Anyway, cyberwarfare is real and it is a growing threat. It is only a matter of time before the cyber version of Pearl Harbor strikes, People will get hurt or killed. We must be ready to attack, defend, or quickly rebuild. And have the flexibility to innovate on the fly.
Business shells out a fortune to deal with cyberattacks, over $388 billion in 2011. And the expanding problems that come with it will increase as well. At some point, some system will shut down that is not just a nuisance for a business' customers, or readers of an online paper.
Some experts believe that pretty soon, people will die. McAfee Labs experts told CNN last January that nation-states will increasingly sponsor and suffer from cyberwarfare. And at some point, people will actually die as a result. That could push the online cold war into a hot phase fairly quickly.
China, Syria, Iran, among others are suspected of launching attacks. And the United States and Israel have initiated skirmishes of their own. According to an Associated Press account from last spring, the Pentagon has assembled 13 separate teams to battle the threat.
Tangential thinking....
I am wondering if the 13 different Defense Department created teams are capable on their own of engaging in this kind of warfare. Obviously they should be a part of it, especially because experts predict that military forces themselves will be targets.
But here's an idea. Bring back the Office of Strategic Services.
The OSS is the precursor of today's CIA. It wasn't the father or the grandfather as much as the crazy uncle of today's buttoned down intelligence bureaucracy. The OSS was established by Franklin Roosevelt in the early stage of World War II. He appointed noted Republican, William "Wild Bill" Donovan, who would eventually earn the rank of general.
Donovan believed in hiring the most talented people possible, regardless of background. He also never saw an idea not worth looking into. Famous playwrights and chefs served in the OSS, including Julia Child. Some ideas were simply awful, such as assembling a collection of German pornography to drop on the Reichschancellory in hopes of driving Hitler insane. Army Air Force chiefs responded that they preferred to bomb the place and kill the Fuehrer, if possible.
On the other hand, the OSS built up guerrilla movements (okay, one of them was Ho Chih Minh), undermined Vichy French control of North Africa, established contact with the head of German military intelligence, and did a fairly credible job. After all, they did start from scratch.
The OSS was famous, or infamous, for a freewheeling style. It was the home of the "so crazy it just might work" mode of operation. James Bond, with his panache and gadgetry, resembled more the agent of OSS than the MI 6 of today.
It would not work to bring back the OSS for its tangible world work in intelligence gathering and operations. We actually have too many different bureaus and organizations scrounging around. A new OSS would scour the country for top talent and channel it towards cyberwarfare, both defense and attack.
A new organization is necessary because it needs an organizational culture all its own. It may need to recruit individuals who have had parking tickets, are less than physically fit, may have consumed drygs at some point, etc. America's cyberenemies come from regimented and strictly authoritarian systems. The best way to drive them cyber crazy is to gather a freewheeling group together to foil it.
This means foiling attacks and launching our own. Find creative ways to apply Sun Tzu to the online world.
Not that previous efforts by the US been without effectiveness or creativity. When a virus shut down Iranian nuclear computers to the tune of AC/DC's "Thunderstruck," that was a nice touch.
Anyway, cyberwarfare is real and it is a growing threat. It is only a matter of time before the cyber version of Pearl Harbor strikes, People will get hurt or killed. We must be ready to attack, defend, or quickly rebuild. And have the flexibility to innovate on the fly.
Wednesday, August 14, 2013
Baltimore Cop Saves Pooch From Ruffians, Breed Specific Legislation Called Into Question
Recently, Baltimore police officer Dan Waskiewicz responded to a vicious dog call. Many of these go unreported in the media and usually end up in the capture of killing of the dog. The officer did not find viciousness in the dog so much as the ruffian children chasing it down the street, pelting it with rocks and bottles.
Baltimore's CBS affiliate reported that Officer Waskiewicz called the dog over. He meekly responded with his tail between his legs. When the policeman bent over to examine him further, the dog responded with kisses.
Waskiewicz put the dog into his squad care where he received more thankful kisses. A spokesman for the Baltimore Humane Society praised the officer's "astute response," adding that he certainly saved a dog's life.
The catch here is that the rescued dog inspires reactive fear at the mere mention of the type or the sight of its bricklike head. Waskiewicz saved the life of an American Pit Bull.
Pit bulls are often targeted by "breed specific legislation" referring to statutes aimed at curbing the ownership and breeding of certain types of dogs deemed dangerous. Two years ago, Waukesha, Wisconsin considered banning pit bulls except for commercial uses. These would include owning them as guard dogs in junk yards.
Last April, Bluefield, West Virginia and its surrounding county of Mercer battled over the breed ban. Bluefield banned pit bulls within city limits and ordered the dogs to be taken to the county animal shelter. Mercer County refused to prevent owners from reclaiming their animals, saying that they "we're not on the dog containment business." The mayor threatened to take the county to court, despite the absence of a state or countywide ban.
Organizations such as Pit Bull Rescue Central claim that the fear stems from hysteria and misinformation. Pit bulls were bred to withstand violent attacks in dogfighting competitions. Breed advocates claim, however, that they are no more inherently violent by nature than many other types of dogs. They emphasize that responsibility for dog behavior lies with owners and how animals are trained and treated.
Another problem is that "pit bulls" are actually not a specific breed, but a group of breeds with similar characteristics. They include the American Staffordshire Terrier. This means that authorities often cannot identify what is and is not actually a pit bull. One city's breed specific legislation was written so poorly that the councilman who proposed the ban saw his own labrador retriever seized.
Officer Waskiewicz's experience does raise questions about breed specific laws aimed at pit bulls. An inherently violent animal in a terrifying experience usually wouldn't react with meekness in that situation. Certainly bad owners make bad dogs. But increasingly, education and awareness have caused many to question blanket laws banning certain breeds
Baltimore's CBS affiliate reported that Officer Waskiewicz called the dog over. He meekly responded with his tail between his legs. When the policeman bent over to examine him further, the dog responded with kisses.
Waskiewicz put the dog into his squad care where he received more thankful kisses. A spokesman for the Baltimore Humane Society praised the officer's "astute response," adding that he certainly saved a dog's life.
The catch here is that the rescued dog inspires reactive fear at the mere mention of the type or the sight of its bricklike head. Waskiewicz saved the life of an American Pit Bull.
Pit bulls are often targeted by "breed specific legislation" referring to statutes aimed at curbing the ownership and breeding of certain types of dogs deemed dangerous. Two years ago, Waukesha, Wisconsin considered banning pit bulls except for commercial uses. These would include owning them as guard dogs in junk yards.
Last April, Bluefield, West Virginia and its surrounding county of Mercer battled over the breed ban. Bluefield banned pit bulls within city limits and ordered the dogs to be taken to the county animal shelter. Mercer County refused to prevent owners from reclaiming their animals, saying that they "we're not on the dog containment business." The mayor threatened to take the county to court, despite the absence of a state or countywide ban.
Organizations such as Pit Bull Rescue Central claim that the fear stems from hysteria and misinformation. Pit bulls were bred to withstand violent attacks in dogfighting competitions. Breed advocates claim, however, that they are no more inherently violent by nature than many other types of dogs. They emphasize that responsibility for dog behavior lies with owners and how animals are trained and treated.
Another problem is that "pit bulls" are actually not a specific breed, but a group of breeds with similar characteristics. They include the American Staffordshire Terrier. This means that authorities often cannot identify what is and is not actually a pit bull. One city's breed specific legislation was written so poorly that the councilman who proposed the ban saw his own labrador retriever seized.
Officer Waskiewicz's experience does raise questions about breed specific laws aimed at pit bulls. An inherently violent animal in a terrifying experience usually wouldn't react with meekness in that situation. Certainly bad owners make bad dogs. But increasingly, education and awareness have caused many to question blanket laws banning certain breeds
Tuesday, August 13, 2013
What About Russian Relations? Obama's Lost Credibility
The Kremlin influenced news outlet Russia Today this week compared Obama's foreign policy stature to Vladimir Putin's using a sports metaphor from European soccer (Barcelona versus Wigan Athletic.) It was somewhat kinder that one published earlier here, which compared Putin to the Harlem Globetrotters and Obama to the perpetually fated square losers, the Washington Generals. The Globetrotters simile is more apt. They dominate with panache and style while their ill matched competitors always seem confused and, well, square.
Putin, like the Globetrotters, plays a different game that Obama and those around him cannot comprehend. This is understandable. Putin once worked in the KGB, responsible for some of the most successful psychological operations ever seen. His worldview developed in the context of a global conflict of perceptions with the United States.
Obama's vision has never really transcended Chicago. His politics are Chicago. He surrounds himself with bit machine politicians. Secretary of State, for Obama, is a box to keep one quiet or a reward for prior support. Imagine if Harry Truman appointed Sam Rayburn as secretary of state and only listened to the advice of Tom Pendergast. How many rings would Stalin have run around the Man from Missouri?
Democrats love to accuse Republicans of knee jerking back to Cold War archetypes. And Obama has gotten sucked into the old mano y mano competitions that Nikita Khrushchev employed successfully at times against John Kennedy and unsuccessfully against Vice President Richard Nixon.
That does not mean, however, that Russia aspires to global revolution. Putin, instead, conducts himself internally and externally much in the same way as the old czars of the imperial age.
Russia, since Peter the Great in the early 1700s, has swung back and forth like a pendulum. Peter the Great imposed Westernization onto Russia in the same way that an abusive parent would force a child to eat broccoli. Westernization was good for Russia, but it never fully developed a taste for strong relations with the West. Out of necessity, or the affinity of the leadership, Russia does "swing" towards the West occasionally. Catherine the Great established intellectual contacts with Voltaire and Jefferson. Boris Yeltsin worked closely with Bill Clinton and Western experts to construct a free market Russia among the shambles of the dead Communist Soviet Union.
On the other hand, Nicholas I cut off all contact with the West and Joseph Stalin initiated the Cold War.
The anti-Western turn is a combination of a reaction against the West and a reaffirmation of traditional Russian identity. Russia suffers from an inferiority complex that has led it in the past to assert that most of the world's great inventions, such as radio and telephones, actually came from there. With inferiority comes a craving for respect. And Russia perceives that Western respect only comes from a show of power and force.
Russia also craves security. And why not, after all, it experienced devastating invasions by Charles XII of Sweden, Napoleon, and Hitler. They prefer to have their enemies far afield and rarely trust professed friends. Russia puts its trust in territory. Keep unfriendly states and alliances as far away as possible while dominating one's neighbors. The Republic of Georgia a few years ago skirmished with Russia. Now they have developed ever closer ties. Belarus seceded from the Soviet Union to escape Great Russia dominance. Now it has devolved into a near protectorate.
Security also comes from international stabilization. The czars despised the idea of any revolution or upheaval against established governments. For example, they warmly supported the United States government in its struggle against the Confederate States, even to the point of deploying warships for a visit to New York harbor. They "helped" Austria in the 1800s by sending in troops to quell a revolt, without that country's invitation. Russia's Syria position reflects this old commitment to what it has always seen as "legitimacy."
Russian foreign relations operate almost entirely on the basis of self-interest. What enhances the prestige and the security of Russia will be pursued. It serves Putin's goals that the United States be raised to the position of antagonist, regardless of what America does or does not do.
Of course the US sometimes plays into anti-Westerners' hands. Criticizing the Chechen War in the 1990s was a terrible misstep. Scolding Russia for its internal developments, negative as they may be, does not advance the US position. Putin's consolidation of power does not threaten the United States, it is not entirely unpopular, and there is little that America can do about it.
Scolding Russia over gay rights and voicing threats about the Olympics does not hurt Putin. It actually reinforces his anti-American message about international meddling. What would really hurt the master of a nation strongly dependent on natural gas revenues is to lift all export controls and turn on as many drills as possible in the US. When the international price of natural gas drops, Russia will be hit. They will also understand that the US can hurt a country without bombing it.
That builds respect. That increases credibility.
Also, make no more mention of anti-gay laws in Russia. Instead, let the gay athletes who will represent the United States compete with class. Jesse Owens and America's Jewish athletes struck a blow against National Socialist doctrines on race and religion by winning events and conducting themselves with honor in Berlin in 1936. They can do the same in Sochi.
No more "resets" can happen under Obama. He has no respect or credibility in the Kremlin. The next president needs to bring people aboard who understand Russia. Then the US can craft a position vis a vis that country that is productive without being subservient.
Putin, like the Globetrotters, plays a different game that Obama and those around him cannot comprehend. This is understandable. Putin once worked in the KGB, responsible for some of the most successful psychological operations ever seen. His worldview developed in the context of a global conflict of perceptions with the United States.
Obama's vision has never really transcended Chicago. His politics are Chicago. He surrounds himself with bit machine politicians. Secretary of State, for Obama, is a box to keep one quiet or a reward for prior support. Imagine if Harry Truman appointed Sam Rayburn as secretary of state and only listened to the advice of Tom Pendergast. How many rings would Stalin have run around the Man from Missouri?
Democrats love to accuse Republicans of knee jerking back to Cold War archetypes. And Obama has gotten sucked into the old mano y mano competitions that Nikita Khrushchev employed successfully at times against John Kennedy and unsuccessfully against Vice President Richard Nixon.
That does not mean, however, that Russia aspires to global revolution. Putin, instead, conducts himself internally and externally much in the same way as the old czars of the imperial age.
Russia, since Peter the Great in the early 1700s, has swung back and forth like a pendulum. Peter the Great imposed Westernization onto Russia in the same way that an abusive parent would force a child to eat broccoli. Westernization was good for Russia, but it never fully developed a taste for strong relations with the West. Out of necessity, or the affinity of the leadership, Russia does "swing" towards the West occasionally. Catherine the Great established intellectual contacts with Voltaire and Jefferson. Boris Yeltsin worked closely with Bill Clinton and Western experts to construct a free market Russia among the shambles of the dead Communist Soviet Union.
On the other hand, Nicholas I cut off all contact with the West and Joseph Stalin initiated the Cold War.
The anti-Western turn is a combination of a reaction against the West and a reaffirmation of traditional Russian identity. Russia suffers from an inferiority complex that has led it in the past to assert that most of the world's great inventions, such as radio and telephones, actually came from there. With inferiority comes a craving for respect. And Russia perceives that Western respect only comes from a show of power and force.
Russia also craves security. And why not, after all, it experienced devastating invasions by Charles XII of Sweden, Napoleon, and Hitler. They prefer to have their enemies far afield and rarely trust professed friends. Russia puts its trust in territory. Keep unfriendly states and alliances as far away as possible while dominating one's neighbors. The Republic of Georgia a few years ago skirmished with Russia. Now they have developed ever closer ties. Belarus seceded from the Soviet Union to escape Great Russia dominance. Now it has devolved into a near protectorate.
Security also comes from international stabilization. The czars despised the idea of any revolution or upheaval against established governments. For example, they warmly supported the United States government in its struggle against the Confederate States, even to the point of deploying warships for a visit to New York harbor. They "helped" Austria in the 1800s by sending in troops to quell a revolt, without that country's invitation. Russia's Syria position reflects this old commitment to what it has always seen as "legitimacy."
Russian foreign relations operate almost entirely on the basis of self-interest. What enhances the prestige and the security of Russia will be pursued. It serves Putin's goals that the United States be raised to the position of antagonist, regardless of what America does or does not do.
Of course the US sometimes plays into anti-Westerners' hands. Criticizing the Chechen War in the 1990s was a terrible misstep. Scolding Russia for its internal developments, negative as they may be, does not advance the US position. Putin's consolidation of power does not threaten the United States, it is not entirely unpopular, and there is little that America can do about it.
Scolding Russia over gay rights and voicing threats about the Olympics does not hurt Putin. It actually reinforces his anti-American message about international meddling. What would really hurt the master of a nation strongly dependent on natural gas revenues is to lift all export controls and turn on as many drills as possible in the US. When the international price of natural gas drops, Russia will be hit. They will also understand that the US can hurt a country without bombing it.
That builds respect. That increases credibility.
Also, make no more mention of anti-gay laws in Russia. Instead, let the gay athletes who will represent the United States compete with class. Jesse Owens and America's Jewish athletes struck a blow against National Socialist doctrines on race and religion by winning events and conducting themselves with honor in Berlin in 1936. They can do the same in Sochi.
No more "resets" can happen under Obama. He has no respect or credibility in the Kremlin. The next president needs to bring people aboard who understand Russia. Then the US can craft a position vis a vis that country that is productive without being subservient.
Monday, August 12, 2013
21st Century Cronyism, Same Old New Jersey
Raymond Chafin in Just Good Politics defined democracy as rewarding as much as possible those most responsible for getting you elected.
The former Logan County boss helped to expose the fact that some politicians consider their constituency to start with those who helped with the campaign, then those who cast their votes for you, then, and then only maybe, the rest of the people. This is an underground culture of politics, lurking beneath the aboveground assertion that all politicians work for "the people."
This is why the New York Times sounded the tocsin on Newark's Democratic mayor (and some say eventual presidential candidate) Cory Booker's techie startup called Waywire.
Booker's startup oozes with revelations common to the confluence of politics and big business. He has strong connections with leading lights at Facebook, LinkedIn, Google, and other companies. Many of them invested heavily in Waywire. Add to the list of investors the ubiquitous Oprah. Although struggling now, it had been expected to perform strongly.
Even more strange, Waywire's brain trust included the 15 year old son of CNN president Jeff Zucker.
Booker certainly understands how to cover media, business, and political bases.
Columbia Journalism Review in their write up added that "Booker will still owe . . . favors even when it (Waywire) goes under."
This is a new twist on an old game. In the 1870s, John D. Rockefeller bought out and propped up West Virginia politico Johnson Newlon Camden. Camden served as Rockefeller's right hand man in West Virginia and rode his patronage to the United States Senate. Doubtless, Booker had hoped that his company would provide him with enough wealth to start a run for president.
No need to worry about Booker going on relief anytime soon. Until he announced his Senate campaign, he collected $30,000 for speeches presented at public universities. And yes, he did speak at West Virginia University.
Booker and his backers both worked hard to build this shady enterprise. Booker expected wealth and strengthening connections with the novae of the tech world. Certainly the tech riche expected some political help in return if Booker made it to the Senate or farther.
The former Logan County boss helped to expose the fact that some politicians consider their constituency to start with those who helped with the campaign, then those who cast their votes for you, then, and then only maybe, the rest of the people. This is an underground culture of politics, lurking beneath the aboveground assertion that all politicians work for "the people."
This is why the New York Times sounded the tocsin on Newark's Democratic mayor (and some say eventual presidential candidate) Cory Booker's techie startup called Waywire.
Booker's startup oozes with revelations common to the confluence of politics and big business. He has strong connections with leading lights at Facebook, LinkedIn, Google, and other companies. Many of them invested heavily in Waywire. Add to the list of investors the ubiquitous Oprah. Although struggling now, it had been expected to perform strongly.
Even more strange, Waywire's brain trust included the 15 year old son of CNN president Jeff Zucker.
Booker certainly understands how to cover media, business, and political bases.
Columbia Journalism Review in their write up added that "Booker will still owe . . . favors even when it (Waywire) goes under."
This is a new twist on an old game. In the 1870s, John D. Rockefeller bought out and propped up West Virginia politico Johnson Newlon Camden. Camden served as Rockefeller's right hand man in West Virginia and rode his patronage to the United States Senate. Doubtless, Booker had hoped that his company would provide him with enough wealth to start a run for president.
No need to worry about Booker going on relief anytime soon. Until he announced his Senate campaign, he collected $30,000 for speeches presented at public universities. And yes, he did speak at West Virginia University.
Booker and his backers both worked hard to build this shady enterprise. Booker expected wealth and strengthening connections with the novae of the tech world. Certainly the tech riche expected some political help in return if Booker made it to the Senate or farther.
Labels:
CNN,
Cory Booker,
Facebook,
Jeff Zucker,
Johnson Camden,
Raymond Chafin
Friday, August 9, 2013
Another Take on Obama's EPA Attacks on Coal and Power Plants
Obama's attacks on power plants and coal mining threaten to take us back to the bad old days, as described by many state historians.
Many historians, chief among them John Alexander Williams of Appalachian State bashed the early industrial development of the state. Most who have ever taken West Virginia history have been taught that companies extracted wealth, shipped it out, and the state never got any benefit.
First off, that assertion is wrong. Historians and others blame the lack of sufficient taxation. But how much could the state have raised taxes before eliminating the competitive advantage enjoyed in attracting the companies in the first place? Benefit comes through the attraction of supporting and satellite industries that expand the ripple effect of wealth extraction.
Coal, timber, and oil companies did bring added economic value to extraction. They employed workers and professionals. Some satellite industries, such as paper mills, grew up in the area. Some railroads were built to support the transport of materials in and out. Could the state's community of capital and political leaders have done a better job in enticing other industries to come in? Certainly. But to say there was no benefit is wrong.
There are at least three stages to development of wealth in extractive industries like coal. First comes the work to get the coal from the ground. Second comes the processing of the material into something useful. A hundred years ago, coke, iron, and steel production used tremendous amounts of coal. Now, much of the coal produces electric power for this part of the nation.
The third part comes in dissemination of the final products.
Unlike our forefathers, the state has succeeded in getting companies interested in taking West Virginia coal and turning it into a useful product within the borders of the state. That would be crucial electric power. Huge facilities such as at Mount Storm and John Amos employ hundreds of state residents in good paying jobs. This is the best way to make sure that the wealth derived from coal stays in the state. Make sure that as much of the production process as is possible remains in West Virginia.
Add to that the fact that cheaper power helps to produce advantages that state officials can use when trying to woo new companies to the state.
But Obama and his EPA have looked at every way possible to shut these plants down, which will have the result of removing wealth and productivity from the state. Whatever coal gets mined will be shipped away with minimal added value to the state and the people.
Exactly what state historians bemoaned about the early industrial period.
Hopefully. West Virginia Democrats made it clear in their EPA meetings that they will not stand for Obama kicking the legs from underneath our chair, economically speaking.
Many historians, chief among them John Alexander Williams of Appalachian State bashed the early industrial development of the state. Most who have ever taken West Virginia history have been taught that companies extracted wealth, shipped it out, and the state never got any benefit.
First off, that assertion is wrong. Historians and others blame the lack of sufficient taxation. But how much could the state have raised taxes before eliminating the competitive advantage enjoyed in attracting the companies in the first place? Benefit comes through the attraction of supporting and satellite industries that expand the ripple effect of wealth extraction.
Coal, timber, and oil companies did bring added economic value to extraction. They employed workers and professionals. Some satellite industries, such as paper mills, grew up in the area. Some railroads were built to support the transport of materials in and out. Could the state's community of capital and political leaders have done a better job in enticing other industries to come in? Certainly. But to say there was no benefit is wrong.
There are at least three stages to development of wealth in extractive industries like coal. First comes the work to get the coal from the ground. Second comes the processing of the material into something useful. A hundred years ago, coke, iron, and steel production used tremendous amounts of coal. Now, much of the coal produces electric power for this part of the nation.
The third part comes in dissemination of the final products.
Unlike our forefathers, the state has succeeded in getting companies interested in taking West Virginia coal and turning it into a useful product within the borders of the state. That would be crucial electric power. Huge facilities such as at Mount Storm and John Amos employ hundreds of state residents in good paying jobs. This is the best way to make sure that the wealth derived from coal stays in the state. Make sure that as much of the production process as is possible remains in West Virginia.
Add to that the fact that cheaper power helps to produce advantages that state officials can use when trying to woo new companies to the state.
But Obama and his EPA have looked at every way possible to shut these plants down, which will have the result of removing wealth and productivity from the state. Whatever coal gets mined will be shipped away with minimal added value to the state and the people.
Exactly what state historians bemoaned about the early industrial period.
Hopefully. West Virginia Democrats made it clear in their EPA meetings that they will not stand for Obama kicking the legs from underneath our chair, economically speaking.
Thursday, August 8, 2013
Common Core Resistance Growing More . . . Common
Underlying themes for the rambling wreck of Obama's presidency can be hard to spot. But one looks pretty clear. Obama and his followers believe that the federal government can take better care of Americans than state and local governments, or even the individuals themselves. Obamacare represents one initiative designed to yank decision-making within the beltway. Farther under the radar lies the Common Core initiative.
Common Core attempts to create national standards of student achievement in key subjects. It relies heavily on standardized testing to quantify learning outcomes.
But now, several states have opted out of the program.
Last week, Georgia joined Alabama, Pennsylvania, Utah, and Oklahoma in making the decision to use their own standardized tests instead of the common national test advocated by Common Core. With such a large defection of key populous states from different regions, Common Core backers complain that the sampling (now at 22) will be unable to give experts a handle on what national standards ought to be.
The Atlanta Journal Constitution reported that state education officials cited cost and efficiency in their judgment to not implement the test. An official said “Georgia can create an equally rigorous
measurement without the high costs associated with this particular test. Just
as we do in all other branches of state government, we can create better value
for taxpayers while maintaining the same level of quality.”
States originally signed onto the program to receive a bribery grant from the Department of Education related to the Race to the Top program. Since receiving the money, many states have balked at certain aspects or dragged their feet. According to a Breitbart evaluation, the tests are long, cost too much money, and assume a higher level of technology than many school systems have.
In other words, Washington education bureaucrats designed something perfect for their suburbs, but not the inner cities or backcountry districts.
The Cato Institute accuses advocates of Common Core of purposeful silence on the issue of how deeply Washington experts were involved in establishing the standards. They say that Common Core may be hoist by this petard. The standards depend upon state testing participation. If states do not participate, the system collapses.
Opposition to Common Core testing does not just come from conservative and libertarian groups. A National Education Association delegate expressed concern over "overtesting and the diminution of instructional time." California Teachers' Association president Dean Fogel adds his concern that "There's nobody in this room, in any town in the whole country, that doesn't understand that this high-stakes testing has raged way out of control. It's time for NEA to tell the truth and be that voice. We have to come out strong and be very clear with people that this high-stakes-testing mania has got to stop."
Why do opponents want to kill Common Core? Besides the expense and time involved, testing in more subjective areas, such as English, could be biased against students from backgrounds different than suburban and affluent urban areas. For example, different regions and communities have different usages of words that are still proper English, but of different usage than elsewhere. States and local districts have a better chance of constructing a test, or different tests, fair to the students in their care
Common Core relies heavily on testing to demonstrate its effectiveness. With opposition coming from teachers' unions and state legislatures to that very thing, national standards advocates may have to go back to the drawing board.
Or the federal government can look at its long record of failure in education and give up its self-assumed role as guider of state and local policy.
Wednesday, August 7, 2013
Far East Dangers Rising On the Horizon
With all the news of China's blue water navy development in the past few years, another country's response fell under the radar. Yesterday, however, the unveiling of Japan's newest "destroyer" raised questions.
The "destroyer" surpasses the size of any Japanese ship built since World War II. To the uneducated (or, perhaps cynical) eye, the Izumo looks suspiciously like an aircraft carrier. Its flat top deck, allegedly meant for helicopters, is four fifths as long as an American Nimitz class deck. It also outstrips by about 200 feet the length of the Royal Navy's Illustrious class carriers
Izumo pointedly responds to China's purchase and reconstruction of a Soviet era carrier from Ukraine.
The bigger issue lies in the deteriorating relations between China and her neighbors, specifically Japan, Vietnam, and the Philippines.
Territorial disputes between these nations lay dormant for years. Recently, technological advances in identifying and extracting sea floor resources have raised the stakes in who owns what stretch of ocean bottom. Vast natural gas and oil resources interest nations, such as China and Japan, that have little of either.
Interestingly, this issue has also separated Cold War partners Japan and the Nationalist Chinese government based in Taiwan.
Throughout the Cold War, the United States played referee to the region. Although domestically debated later, the willingness to fight in Korea and Vietnam gave friends assurance and enemies pause. Few doubted America's willingness to fight for Japan, South Korea, Nationalist China, or other friends. Moreover, few believed that the US had any goals in the Far East beyond maintaining the status quo.
American power, relatively speaking, has receded in the region as China spent more on expanding and modernizing its warmaking ability. It also has launched cyberattacks against its opponents' government and business concerns.
Unfortunately for the United States, the Chinese urge to revise the Far East balance of power echoes the shadows of a century ago.
In 1913, the British Empire managed the world power dynamic through a powerful navy and economic productive might. The German Empire under Kaiser William II aspired to "a place in the sun." This meant military might, colonial expansion, and international respect on par with the British.
They made an unwise alliance with unstable Austria-Hungary, which was locked in perpetual disputes with Russia over control of southeastern Europe. When Russia's client state of Serbia served as the base of a devastating terror attack on Austria-Hungary, the clumsy attempt to settle the score touched off World War I.
Similar dynamics are emerging now. China is setting itself against Japan, the Philippines, and Vietnam in its territorial disputes. It has an unstable client in North Korea whose unpredictability could touch off a war with Japan or South Korea. It is trying, like Germany in the early 1900s, to build a fleet that can regionally challenge the first rank power.
In other words, a pattern is emerging that could unravel decades of generally peaceful relations among states that despise and fear each other.
China's bold actions mirror those of other states that fear internal discord and try to rally the people around external successes. It built a middle class, but never allowed it political participation. That has been the downfall of many authoritarian regimes. Questions about its debt and actual production numbers lend uncertainty to the perception that it is an economic power fated to outstrip the United States.
This also comes at a time when the Middle East's foundations of stability are collapsing, leftist regimes have come to power in Latin America, and Europe continues to live on the precipice of debt disaster.
Events have pushed the world's nations and people towards a time where only the brilliance of a Prince Otto von Bismarck could restore the balance. It would be in America's interest to produce such a figure because a war in the Far East would inevitably draw us in. And like Germany in the late 1800s and early 1900s, very few possible scenarios, even in victory, leave the US better off.
The "destroyer" surpasses the size of any Japanese ship built since World War II. To the uneducated (or, perhaps cynical) eye, the Izumo looks suspiciously like an aircraft carrier. Its flat top deck, allegedly meant for helicopters, is four fifths as long as an American Nimitz class deck. It also outstrips by about 200 feet the length of the Royal Navy's Illustrious class carriers
Izumo pointedly responds to China's purchase and reconstruction of a Soviet era carrier from Ukraine.
The bigger issue lies in the deteriorating relations between China and her neighbors, specifically Japan, Vietnam, and the Philippines.
Territorial disputes between these nations lay dormant for years. Recently, technological advances in identifying and extracting sea floor resources have raised the stakes in who owns what stretch of ocean bottom. Vast natural gas and oil resources interest nations, such as China and Japan, that have little of either.
Interestingly, this issue has also separated Cold War partners Japan and the Nationalist Chinese government based in Taiwan.
Throughout the Cold War, the United States played referee to the region. Although domestically debated later, the willingness to fight in Korea and Vietnam gave friends assurance and enemies pause. Few doubted America's willingness to fight for Japan, South Korea, Nationalist China, or other friends. Moreover, few believed that the US had any goals in the Far East beyond maintaining the status quo.
American power, relatively speaking, has receded in the region as China spent more on expanding and modernizing its warmaking ability. It also has launched cyberattacks against its opponents' government and business concerns.
Unfortunately for the United States, the Chinese urge to revise the Far East balance of power echoes the shadows of a century ago.
In 1913, the British Empire managed the world power dynamic through a powerful navy and economic productive might. The German Empire under Kaiser William II aspired to "a place in the sun." This meant military might, colonial expansion, and international respect on par with the British.
They made an unwise alliance with unstable Austria-Hungary, which was locked in perpetual disputes with Russia over control of southeastern Europe. When Russia's client state of Serbia served as the base of a devastating terror attack on Austria-Hungary, the clumsy attempt to settle the score touched off World War I.
Similar dynamics are emerging now. China is setting itself against Japan, the Philippines, and Vietnam in its territorial disputes. It has an unstable client in North Korea whose unpredictability could touch off a war with Japan or South Korea. It is trying, like Germany in the early 1900s, to build a fleet that can regionally challenge the first rank power.
In other words, a pattern is emerging that could unravel decades of generally peaceful relations among states that despise and fear each other.
China's bold actions mirror those of other states that fear internal discord and try to rally the people around external successes. It built a middle class, but never allowed it political participation. That has been the downfall of many authoritarian regimes. Questions about its debt and actual production numbers lend uncertainty to the perception that it is an economic power fated to outstrip the United States.
This also comes at a time when the Middle East's foundations of stability are collapsing, leftist regimes have come to power in Latin America, and Europe continues to live on the precipice of debt disaster.
Events have pushed the world's nations and people towards a time where only the brilliance of a Prince Otto von Bismarck could restore the balance. It would be in America's interest to produce such a figure because a war in the Far East would inevitably draw us in. And like Germany in the late 1800s and early 1900s, very few possible scenarios, even in victory, leave the US better off.
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
Abuse of Information Database Is Too Commonplace
Last week, the nation was jarred by the news that a couple searched "backpack" and "pressure cooker," then found armed police at their door soon thereafter. While it turned out that their internet provider actually turned in the tip, other NSA scandals have enraged and frightened many.
Defenders of information collection argue that what is collected rarely gets used. And then, only by professionals with good reason to use it. Unfortunately, people being who they are, abuse can always happen.
The Washington Guardian recently reported that New York City Police Department detectives have routinely abused the privilege of accessing the FBI's National Crime Information Center database. While only authorized to use it during car stops and investigations, some officers have used it to snoop on fellow officers and even tip off criminals. Some of the most egregious cases involve officers identifying drug criminals so that they can rob them.
Safeguards exist, but experts claim that abusers can easily circumvent them.
This adds to worries that the National Security Agency has distributed information to agencies that investigate domestic crime and not national security. Reuters reports that the NSA sent information to the Drug Enforcement Agency's Special Operations Division. Although the information shared cannot be used because of Constitutional restrictions, DEA investigators are trained to backtrack and build a conventional looking investigation that does not use illegal data.
Many fear that high level politicians will always face temptations to misuse information at their disposal. The administrations of Franklin Roosevelt, Richard Nixon, and Barack Obama all misused IRS information. Eliot Spitzer, while governor of New York, misused police documents to smear a Republican opponent.
Information gained for law enforcement and/or national security purposes can help to protect the nation, lives, and property. Living without it means accepting complete vulnerability. But like any other extension of government power, the intelligence and law enforcement fields need to have strong boundaries and competent oversight. Rule of law and natural rights principles demand no less.
Defenders of information collection argue that what is collected rarely gets used. And then, only by professionals with good reason to use it. Unfortunately, people being who they are, abuse can always happen.
The Washington Guardian recently reported that New York City Police Department detectives have routinely abused the privilege of accessing the FBI's National Crime Information Center database. While only authorized to use it during car stops and investigations, some officers have used it to snoop on fellow officers and even tip off criminals. Some of the most egregious cases involve officers identifying drug criminals so that they can rob them.
Safeguards exist, but experts claim that abusers can easily circumvent them.
This adds to worries that the National Security Agency has distributed information to agencies that investigate domestic crime and not national security. Reuters reports that the NSA sent information to the Drug Enforcement Agency's Special Operations Division. Although the information shared cannot be used because of Constitutional restrictions, DEA investigators are trained to backtrack and build a conventional looking investigation that does not use illegal data.
Many fear that high level politicians will always face temptations to misuse information at their disposal. The administrations of Franklin Roosevelt, Richard Nixon, and Barack Obama all misused IRS information. Eliot Spitzer, while governor of New York, misused police documents to smear a Republican opponent.
Information gained for law enforcement and/or national security purposes can help to protect the nation, lives, and property. Living without it means accepting complete vulnerability. But like any other extension of government power, the intelligence and law enforcement fields need to have strong boundaries and competent oversight. Rule of law and natural rights principles demand no less.
Labels:
DEA,
FBI,
New York City Police Department,
NSA,
Washington Guardian
Monday, August 5, 2013
The Power of Old, New, and Social Media to Right a Wrong
Jake Tapper, once of ABC, now with his own show on CNN, tweeted at about 9 PM last night at TMobile's corporate Twitter. Apparently, they had been billing a KIA's widow for three years for an old phone that was not in her name.
She sent death certificates and pleas to stop sending her husband the bill to no avail.
So Jake Tapper called TMobile out on it. He asked
@TMobile what does she have to do for you to stop sending her dead KIA soldier ex-husband these bills???
This morning the CEO of TMobile, John Legere sent several responses apologizing and thanking Tapper for bringing the story to light.
He also tweeted:
@jaketapper don't thank me. It's a sickening shame it happened . I am deeply sorry and have already handled it. Thank you for speaking out.
This is exactly how we want our companies to respond when something is clearly wrong. Take responsibility, apologize, fix it.
Great job to Tapper and Legere.
She sent death certificates and pleas to stop sending her husband the bill to no avail.
So Jake Tapper called TMobile out on it. He asked
@TMobile what does she have to do for you to stop sending her dead KIA soldier ex-husband these bills???
This morning the CEO of TMobile, John Legere sent several responses apologizing and thanking Tapper for bringing the story to light.
He also tweeted:
@jaketapper don't thank me. It's a sickening shame it happened . I am deeply sorry and have already handled it. Thank you for speaking out.
This is exactly how we want our companies to respond when something is clearly wrong. Take responsibility, apologize, fix it.
Great job to Tapper and Legere.
Labels:
CNN,
Jake Tapper,
John Legere,
TMobile,
Twitter
The Rise of the Sports Mass Media Industrial Complex Oligolopoly
In Boston, the owner of the Red Sox threw some petty cash around and bought one of the town's major metropolitan dailies.
In Morgantown, disputes over Tier 3 broadcasting rights threw the old college town into a tizzy, hammered a wedge between two state Republican Party titans, and smashed a decades old relationship between the university and a media company.
ESPN long ago absorbed a traditional television network and an entertainment company. Then it ran its bull through college sports' china shop, smashing conferences and forcing decisions on what defined a college sports program as "viable." The American free market has sent two St. Georges, Fox Sports and NBC, to slay the dragon.
But that story is still developing.
These developments lead observers to ask, is the current fast inflation of the sports industry and its media handmaidens economically or ethically good for either?
Columbia Journalism Review analyzed the sharp rise in the value of sports franchises, as well as the coincidental correlation with the decline of traditional media, especially print. It posed the question, can a hometown media outlet report fairly on a sports issue if it is linked with the franchise?
CJR answers the question by pointing out how poorly ESPN has covered stories in which it plays a central role.
Media tend to perform poorly when interests collide. CJR speculates that the Boston Globe will have a harder time covering the team honestly when its parent company owns the Red Sox. But this is hardly a unique situation. When owned by General Electric, NBC tread very carefully when covering stories about its parent company. Media outlets often face important decisions and criticism when dealing with stories involving critical advertisers.
Another problem with the sports mass media blobonomy is that there has to be a saturation point. There are only so many sports fans. There can be only so much interest here and abroad. Rules changes done for safety or (more often) public relations transform the games, frustrating traditional fans.
Rising prices have created an impact as well. The cost of tickets and merchandise either now, or soon will, exceed the value of the product. Players' and owners drives to profit as much as possible rely on a steep willingness of the market to pay. What is the cost to the sport's profitability if children have less and less opportunity to see the games in person?
Franchises and media increasingly aim at sports followers instead of fans. Serious differences separate the devoted latter from the fickle former.
A warning comes from the fate of American boxing. Once one of the most popular sports in the nation, it died because the sports' foremost figures decided that it could thrive by forcing anyone interested in watching premiere events to pay through the nose. Boxing still makes money, but how many Americans can name the heavyweight champion right now, let alone any contenders?
Anyone who thinks that bad decisions by the major sports could not reduce any of them in a generation to the status of boxing is delusional.
Sports teams' value comes entirely from the perception by their markets that an experience involving them has value. No one needs to consume the product to survive. No one needs the product to help them understand the world better. That is why the notion of franchises worth over a billion is troubling. At the end of the day, they don't make anything of substance. How long can the market sustain them, especially given a seemingly never ending economic slump?
In other words, the sports media industry displays many of the classic features of an economic bubble, except for the availability of too easily obtained credit. Nothing grows this fast forever and leisure spending is fickle.
And this is not meant to be a hand wringing, what-is-to-be-done, kind of commentary. Making money honestly is no sin. But, like any other industry, those invested and involved need to understand that no sure fire never fail model has ever existed. What goes up tends to come down. And if mass media outlets tie themselves too securely to the sports industry ship, they may sink with it should market priorities change.
In Morgantown, disputes over Tier 3 broadcasting rights threw the old college town into a tizzy, hammered a wedge between two state Republican Party titans, and smashed a decades old relationship between the university and a media company.
ESPN long ago absorbed a traditional television network and an entertainment company. Then it ran its bull through college sports' china shop, smashing conferences and forcing decisions on what defined a college sports program as "viable." The American free market has sent two St. Georges, Fox Sports and NBC, to slay the dragon.
But that story is still developing.
These developments lead observers to ask, is the current fast inflation of the sports industry and its media handmaidens economically or ethically good for either?
Columbia Journalism Review analyzed the sharp rise in the value of sports franchises, as well as the coincidental correlation with the decline of traditional media, especially print. It posed the question, can a hometown media outlet report fairly on a sports issue if it is linked with the franchise?
CJR answers the question by pointing out how poorly ESPN has covered stories in which it plays a central role.
Media tend to perform poorly when interests collide. CJR speculates that the Boston Globe will have a harder time covering the team honestly when its parent company owns the Red Sox. But this is hardly a unique situation. When owned by General Electric, NBC tread very carefully when covering stories about its parent company. Media outlets often face important decisions and criticism when dealing with stories involving critical advertisers.
Another problem with the sports mass media blobonomy is that there has to be a saturation point. There are only so many sports fans. There can be only so much interest here and abroad. Rules changes done for safety or (more often) public relations transform the games, frustrating traditional fans.
Rising prices have created an impact as well. The cost of tickets and merchandise either now, or soon will, exceed the value of the product. Players' and owners drives to profit as much as possible rely on a steep willingness of the market to pay. What is the cost to the sport's profitability if children have less and less opportunity to see the games in person?
Franchises and media increasingly aim at sports followers instead of fans. Serious differences separate the devoted latter from the fickle former.
A warning comes from the fate of American boxing. Once one of the most popular sports in the nation, it died because the sports' foremost figures decided that it could thrive by forcing anyone interested in watching premiere events to pay through the nose. Boxing still makes money, but how many Americans can name the heavyweight champion right now, let alone any contenders?
Anyone who thinks that bad decisions by the major sports could not reduce any of them in a generation to the status of boxing is delusional.
Sports teams' value comes entirely from the perception by their markets that an experience involving them has value. No one needs to consume the product to survive. No one needs the product to help them understand the world better. That is why the notion of franchises worth over a billion is troubling. At the end of the day, they don't make anything of substance. How long can the market sustain them, especially given a seemingly never ending economic slump?
In other words, the sports media industry displays many of the classic features of an economic bubble, except for the availability of too easily obtained credit. Nothing grows this fast forever and leisure spending is fickle.
And this is not meant to be a hand wringing, what-is-to-be-done, kind of commentary. Making money honestly is no sin. But, like any other industry, those invested and involved need to understand that no sure fire never fail model has ever existed. What goes up tends to come down. And if mass media outlets tie themselves too securely to the sports industry ship, they may sink with it should market priorities change.
Friday, August 2, 2013
Was West Virginia a Victim of the Free Market?
And now a rare first person commentary!
I have wrestled with the idea of the "robber baron" theory of West Virginia economic development since I was in college. Historians such as John Alexander Williams taught for decades that a once pristine and functional society fell victim to greedy and rapacious seizers of land and resources. They squeezed the land and people dry of wealth, then abandoned the state for greener pastures in the 20th century. This left the state with little to show for the sacrifices made.
Taking another look at this time is vital. Historians and the books they write almost uniformly blame the free market for all the evils that took place. This mainly comes from the fact that many of them fail to see that a truly competitive free market defended by rule of law is not synonymous with doing business. Many of the abuses done by business and described by historians are the opposite of the free market.
Williams grafted a colonial-periphery theory from studies of the Third World. In his explanation, West Virginia was a "colony" of New York based business interests. They recruited and used a comprador class of local lawyers and other professionals to advance their interests and to get the people behind them. This theory, advanced by many, portrays a naïve population duped, used, and left behind. They made little intellectual contribution, so they bear little responsibility.
Others, such as West Virginia University's Ron Lewis, have described more moderate ideas that do not reduce either the businessmen nor the state's people to caricatures. Lewis' works focus as much on the environmental sacrifices as well as the social and economic ones.
One cannot argue away the fact that West Virginia's environment was drastically changed by industrialization. Lewis in Transformation of the Appalachian Countryside describes how practices of getting timber to market caused eroded hillsides, made vast areas more vulnerable to both floods and fire, and annihilated river life. He also points out that the clear cutting actually worked to the economic detriment of the logging companies because the land could not renew its forests quickly.
So there was environmental sacrifice on the same lines as the rest of a country untutored in best practices. Interestingly, the example of West Virginia and other Appalachian states (clear cutting removed almost all of the virgin forest in the region) showed the resiliency of the environment instead of the fragility. Forests and streams rebounded fairly quickly.
And the environmental impact did not start with the Industrial Revolution, either. Traveling writer Anne Royall described the stripping of forests around the Kanawha Valley salt works in the first decade of the 19th century. She talked about the ugly, stump ridden hillsides and the black smoke hanging in the air. Before the salt industry, Indians and frontier farmers used rather wasteful methods to remove trees, farm a plot until the land wore out, then move on.
The crux of the economic argument discussed by historians (but rebutted by economists such as Russ Sobel) is that wealth was "stolen" from West Virginia.
Did greed and hatred for humanity cause businessmen to swindle the people from their land, then force them into unhealthy jobs that paid nothing? And did the state get nothing in return?
The record is mixed. Some focus on the amount of money paid to landowners for their property. Owners received a pittance compared to the value of resources removed. In many cases, this is true. The true market value of land isolated from centers of transportation and unsuitable for farming was very low. Company agents looking for coal lands offered market value. Some recognized the eagerness in the eyes of the agents and negotiated for more. Others savored the idea of getting more cash than they had likely ever seen in their lives for what they thought was worth very little and took the offer without question or counterproposal.
But other owners refused to sell. Companies then brought in the lawyers. Land claims in the mountains of what was once Virginia were a tangled mess. People established claims with boundaries marked by trees or moss covered rocks, laid out in paces. Different land offices granted the same land to separate people. Residents lived on the land they thought was theirs. Companies in Philadelphia, New York, and elsewhere bought competing claims.
So naturally many cases ended up in court. With no clear ownership of the land established, judges had to fall back on legal principle. Here is yet another example where government meddling in the private sector creates social problems. Before the Industrial Revolution, courts in Western Virginia used natural rights and common law principles. The rights of the individual were more important than those of collective society. With all else equal, a court would usually use the maxim "possession is 9/10 of the law." The person living on the land, all else being equal, gets to keep the land.
After industrialism took hold, courts moved to a collectivist social justice approach. The maxim now was to advance the common good. In any era, the common good is usually defined by entities trying to take resources from the less powerful individual for some other purpose. Collectivism was on the side of big business. So instead of advising the companies to make better offers or go elsewhere, courts ruled in favor of the companies "for the common good."
The common good was also supposedly advanced by a law allowing railroads to be built without permission on private land if the owners did not notice the construction of the rail line.
Common good arguments are just as nefarious when done in favor of modern causes as they were when done to advance crony capitalist interests. Every time used, the common good argument hurts the common individual man. They are rarely appropriate in a free society, even if the common good is advanced.
And the common good did advance. It could have advanced just as far, if not farther, had the rights of individuals remained respected. But advance, it did. Railroads connected most towns and county seats. Mind you, sometimes the county seats were moved by force to the rail lines in some cases. But it happened.
Satellite industries grew up around timber and coal extraction. Paper mills, coke ovens, glassware, and other products were churned out of towns and cities across the state. Trains and river traffic carried products to domestic markets and port cities. The free public school system advanced farther and faster after the Civil War than nearly anywhere else south of the Potomac and Ohio Rivers.
At the time of the industrial revolution, dredged rivers, expanding rail networks, and establishment of free schools were all marks of progress. West Virginia got those and a government weather station.
The argument that naïve or greedy natives sold out to big city interests falls flat. Henry Gassaway Davis of Piedmont was a mover in politics and business, not one who was moved. Elkins, who politically advised presidents and would-be presidents, chose to move to the state. Johnson Camden did sell out his oil and gas interests to John Rockefeller in a Godfather-like "offer you can't refuse." But that was under pressure of riches or ruin and was the aberration instead of the rule.
Employment of the people also created a mixed result. Abuses did happen, particularly in the southern counties. Some companies took advantage of the isolation, using debt and low wages to create near serfdom style conditions in company towns. The company owned the houses, stores, schools, and even churches. Running afoul of the company meant a blacklisting from almost any job in the region.
Again, government and business worked too closely in unison in these areas. Many sheriff's deputies worked double duty as law enforcement and company guards. Law enforcement broke up the free association of union organizers and workers while also intimidating journalists. The stifling hand of government allied with business perpetuated these abuses. It is a sin of business, but not one of the free market.
On the other hand, those now working for cash money had more access to the benefits of industrialism. Historians bemoan the move from self-sufficiency to the market economy. But they do not consider the price of items compared to the value of the time spent in making them oneself. Factory made clothes could be bought for cash earned in less time than it took mom or grandma to make homespun. Food was cheaper when considered in this way. People also had access to medicine, newspapers, and other products rarely seen in some areas prior to the coming of industrialization. Standards of living rose for most people.
Of course the downside lay in the fact that a cash paying job provided less security. What happened to people laid off, too old, or too injured to work was a real social problem.
Overall, it is hard to see how one could find that business as a collective whole abused or stole from the state and people of West Virginia. Then, as before and later, individual malefactors took advantage of people and the laxity of the laws. But they do as much or more harm now by lobbying to use the power of government to eliminate competitors, or infringe on the rights of the people.
Revisiting the interpretation of industrial history in West Virginia is necessary. The perceived sins of the past are used against those trying to develop for the future. We have all been raised to wrongly blame the free market system when many of the real problems stemmed from government help. Except for the environmental destruction, which a more educated society and legal system has addressed adequately, the free market ideal is just not responsible
The lesson of West Virginia's past is not that the free market failed, it is that the failure to maintain a free market hurt the people.
I have wrestled with the idea of the "robber baron" theory of West Virginia economic development since I was in college. Historians such as John Alexander Williams taught for decades that a once pristine and functional society fell victim to greedy and rapacious seizers of land and resources. They squeezed the land and people dry of wealth, then abandoned the state for greener pastures in the 20th century. This left the state with little to show for the sacrifices made.
Taking another look at this time is vital. Historians and the books they write almost uniformly blame the free market for all the evils that took place. This mainly comes from the fact that many of them fail to see that a truly competitive free market defended by rule of law is not synonymous with doing business. Many of the abuses done by business and described by historians are the opposite of the free market.
Williams grafted a colonial-periphery theory from studies of the Third World. In his explanation, West Virginia was a "colony" of New York based business interests. They recruited and used a comprador class of local lawyers and other professionals to advance their interests and to get the people behind them. This theory, advanced by many, portrays a naïve population duped, used, and left behind. They made little intellectual contribution, so they bear little responsibility.
Others, such as West Virginia University's Ron Lewis, have described more moderate ideas that do not reduce either the businessmen nor the state's people to caricatures. Lewis' works focus as much on the environmental sacrifices as well as the social and economic ones.
One cannot argue away the fact that West Virginia's environment was drastically changed by industrialization. Lewis in Transformation of the Appalachian Countryside describes how practices of getting timber to market caused eroded hillsides, made vast areas more vulnerable to both floods and fire, and annihilated river life. He also points out that the clear cutting actually worked to the economic detriment of the logging companies because the land could not renew its forests quickly.
So there was environmental sacrifice on the same lines as the rest of a country untutored in best practices. Interestingly, the example of West Virginia and other Appalachian states (clear cutting removed almost all of the virgin forest in the region) showed the resiliency of the environment instead of the fragility. Forests and streams rebounded fairly quickly.
And the environmental impact did not start with the Industrial Revolution, either. Traveling writer Anne Royall described the stripping of forests around the Kanawha Valley salt works in the first decade of the 19th century. She talked about the ugly, stump ridden hillsides and the black smoke hanging in the air. Before the salt industry, Indians and frontier farmers used rather wasteful methods to remove trees, farm a plot until the land wore out, then move on.
The crux of the economic argument discussed by historians (but rebutted by economists such as Russ Sobel) is that wealth was "stolen" from West Virginia.
Did greed and hatred for humanity cause businessmen to swindle the people from their land, then force them into unhealthy jobs that paid nothing? And did the state get nothing in return?
The record is mixed. Some focus on the amount of money paid to landowners for their property. Owners received a pittance compared to the value of resources removed. In many cases, this is true. The true market value of land isolated from centers of transportation and unsuitable for farming was very low. Company agents looking for coal lands offered market value. Some recognized the eagerness in the eyes of the agents and negotiated for more. Others savored the idea of getting more cash than they had likely ever seen in their lives for what they thought was worth very little and took the offer without question or counterproposal.
But other owners refused to sell. Companies then brought in the lawyers. Land claims in the mountains of what was once Virginia were a tangled mess. People established claims with boundaries marked by trees or moss covered rocks, laid out in paces. Different land offices granted the same land to separate people. Residents lived on the land they thought was theirs. Companies in Philadelphia, New York, and elsewhere bought competing claims.
So naturally many cases ended up in court. With no clear ownership of the land established, judges had to fall back on legal principle. Here is yet another example where government meddling in the private sector creates social problems. Before the Industrial Revolution, courts in Western Virginia used natural rights and common law principles. The rights of the individual were more important than those of collective society. With all else equal, a court would usually use the maxim "possession is 9/10 of the law." The person living on the land, all else being equal, gets to keep the land.
After industrialism took hold, courts moved to a collectivist social justice approach. The maxim now was to advance the common good. In any era, the common good is usually defined by entities trying to take resources from the less powerful individual for some other purpose. Collectivism was on the side of big business. So instead of advising the companies to make better offers or go elsewhere, courts ruled in favor of the companies "for the common good."
The common good was also supposedly advanced by a law allowing railroads to be built without permission on private land if the owners did not notice the construction of the rail line.
Common good arguments are just as nefarious when done in favor of modern causes as they were when done to advance crony capitalist interests. Every time used, the common good argument hurts the common individual man. They are rarely appropriate in a free society, even if the common good is advanced.
And the common good did advance. It could have advanced just as far, if not farther, had the rights of individuals remained respected. But advance, it did. Railroads connected most towns and county seats. Mind you, sometimes the county seats were moved by force to the rail lines in some cases. But it happened.
Satellite industries grew up around timber and coal extraction. Paper mills, coke ovens, glassware, and other products were churned out of towns and cities across the state. Trains and river traffic carried products to domestic markets and port cities. The free public school system advanced farther and faster after the Civil War than nearly anywhere else south of the Potomac and Ohio Rivers.
At the time of the industrial revolution, dredged rivers, expanding rail networks, and establishment of free schools were all marks of progress. West Virginia got those and a government weather station.
The argument that naïve or greedy natives sold out to big city interests falls flat. Henry Gassaway Davis of Piedmont was a mover in politics and business, not one who was moved. Elkins, who politically advised presidents and would-be presidents, chose to move to the state. Johnson Camden did sell out his oil and gas interests to John Rockefeller in a Godfather-like "offer you can't refuse." But that was under pressure of riches or ruin and was the aberration instead of the rule.
Employment of the people also created a mixed result. Abuses did happen, particularly in the southern counties. Some companies took advantage of the isolation, using debt and low wages to create near serfdom style conditions in company towns. The company owned the houses, stores, schools, and even churches. Running afoul of the company meant a blacklisting from almost any job in the region.
Again, government and business worked too closely in unison in these areas. Many sheriff's deputies worked double duty as law enforcement and company guards. Law enforcement broke up the free association of union organizers and workers while also intimidating journalists. The stifling hand of government allied with business perpetuated these abuses. It is a sin of business, but not one of the free market.
On the other hand, those now working for cash money had more access to the benefits of industrialism. Historians bemoan the move from self-sufficiency to the market economy. But they do not consider the price of items compared to the value of the time spent in making them oneself. Factory made clothes could be bought for cash earned in less time than it took mom or grandma to make homespun. Food was cheaper when considered in this way. People also had access to medicine, newspapers, and other products rarely seen in some areas prior to the coming of industrialization. Standards of living rose for most people.
Of course the downside lay in the fact that a cash paying job provided less security. What happened to people laid off, too old, or too injured to work was a real social problem.
Overall, it is hard to see how one could find that business as a collective whole abused or stole from the state and people of West Virginia. Then, as before and later, individual malefactors took advantage of people and the laxity of the laws. But they do as much or more harm now by lobbying to use the power of government to eliminate competitors, or infringe on the rights of the people.
Revisiting the interpretation of industrial history in West Virginia is necessary. The perceived sins of the past are used against those trying to develop for the future. We have all been raised to wrongly blame the free market system when many of the real problems stemmed from government help. Except for the environmental destruction, which a more educated society and legal system has addressed adequately, the free market ideal is just not responsible
The lesson of West Virginia's past is not that the free market failed, it is that the failure to maintain a free market hurt the people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)